Find the best product instantly

Loading
Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019)
Apple HomePod (2018)
See Top Ranked Smart Speakers

Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019) vs Apple HomePod (2018)

Analysis:

The Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019) is an example of a great Smart Speaker at its $35 budget.

In the case of the $299 Apple HomePod (2018), however, we weren't able to find enough data to come to any reliable conclusions. If you're considering buying a Smart Speaker in the $390 range, we encourage you to take a look at some other options.

The Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019) managed to impress reviewers from two reliable and unbiased sources that conduct their own hands-on testing, namely Android Central, PCmag, Tom's Guide, Expert Reviews, and Tech Advisor. It performed great in their roundups - it earned the "Best Value" title from Android Central and "Best for Nightstands and Desks" from PCmag, which makes it a product worthy of consideration.

Returning to the Apple HomePod (2018) - it was really well-received by reviewers at PCmag and Wirecutter, which are among the most highly trusted sources on the internet and are known for their in-depth hands-on testing. It was named "Best for Apple-centric Audiophiles" by PCmag and "Best smart speaker for HomeKit" by Wirecutter, which points toward the Apple HomePod (2018) being a high-quality product.

To get a better idea of how they fare when compared directly to each other, we analyzed review scores of sources that tested both. Expert Reviews, Pocket-lint, Top Ten Reviews, TrustedReviews, Techradar, PCmag, Tom's Guide, CNET, The Verge, TechHive, The Ambient, and Digitaltrends, for example, preferred the Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019), while What Hi-Fi? rated both of them the same.

We also took a look at which sources had the best things to say about them. We learned that the Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019) got reviewed the highest by Expert Reviews - it gave it a rating of 10, while the Apple HomePod (2018) most impressed reviewers at What Hi-Fi?, which gave it a score of 10.

Lastly, we averaged out all of their review ratings and observed that the Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019), with its 9.0 average, performed considerably better than most Smart Speakers - the mean score for the product category being 7.4 out of 10 - while the Apple HomePod (2018) managed an average of 7.2.

There's one caveat here - it might not be entirely justifiable to do a direct Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019) vs. Apple HomePod (2018) review average comparison since they aren't priced the same and more expensive products tend to get higher review scores from some sources.

Comparison of expert ratings
Highly Recommended
Recommended
Mentioned
Not Mentioned
PCmag
Tom's Guide
Wirecutter
Android Central
Tech Advisor
Expert Reviews
CNET
TrustedReviews
The Verge
Techradar
Tech. Specs Comparison
Amazon Echo Dot with Clock (2019)
$44
Apple HomePod (2018)
$299
Highly recommended by trusted experts
Tom's Guide
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The best smart home devices in 2020” 
Last updated: 7 days ago
PCmag
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The Best Smart Speakers for 2020” 
Last updated: 24 Apr 2020
Expert Reviews
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Best alarm clock: Guaranteed wake-up calls from just £25” 
Last updated: 8 Apr 2020
Android Central
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Save on Amazon's new Echo Dot with Clock, Echo Dot Kids Edition, and more” 
Last updated: 1 Nov 2019
Tech Advisor
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Rated 9.0 out of 10
in “Best Amazon Echo 2020” 
Last updated: 18 Mar 2020
TrustedReviews
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #5 out of 10
in “Best smart speakers 2020: Smarten up your home” 
Last updated: 14 Feb 2020
PCmag
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best for Nightstands and Desks
in “The Best Bluetooth Speakers Under $100” 
Last updated: 16 Apr 2020
Tom's Guide
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #4 out of 10
in “The best Alexa speakers in 2020” 
Last updated: 7 days ago
Android Central
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “Best Work From Home Desk Accessories in 2020” 
Last updated: 12 Mar 2020
Tech Advisor
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Rated 9.0 out of 10
in “Best smart speakers 2020” 
Last updated: 2 Jan 2020
Android Central
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “Best Alexa-enabled Speakers in 2020” 
Last updated: 7 Jan 2020
Android Central
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Value
in “Best Smart Speaker in 2020: Echo vs. Google Home vs. Sonos” 
Last updated: 16 days ago
CNET
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The best alarm clock for 2020” 
Last updated: 30 Mar 2020
Highly recommended by trusted experts
Wirecutter
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Apple HomePod Review: It Only Sounds Great” 
Last updated: 4 Jun 2019
PCmag
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best for Apple-centric Audiophiles
in “The Best Smart Speakers for 2020” 
Last updated: 24 Apr 2020
Tom's Guide
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 6
in “The best smart home hubs of 2020” 
Last updated: 18 days ago
Good Housekeeping
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The best smart speakers” 
Last updated: 28 Jan 2019
Techradar
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The best smart speakers 2020: which one should you buy?” 
Last updated: 26 Mar 2020
CNET
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best sound overall
in “The best smart speakers of 2020: Get hands-free help from Amazon, Google or Apple” 
Last updated: 2 Apr 2020
Tech Advisor
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Rated 8.0 out of 10
in “Best smart speakers 2020” 
Last updated: 2 Jan 2020
TrustedReviews
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 10
in “Best smart speakers 2020: Smarten up your home” 
Last updated: 14 Feb 2020
Wirecutter
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The Best HomeKit-Compatible Smart-Home Devices” 
Last updated: 20 Dec 2019
CNET
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best for Apple fans
in “Best Wi-Fi speakers of 2020: Apple, Sonos, Polk and Ikea” 
Last updated: 1 Mar 2020
Techradar
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #8 out of 9
in “Best AirPlay speakers: the best Apple-friendly wireless speakers in 2020” 
Last updated: 28 Jan 2020
Expert Reviews
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best smart speaker 2020: The top smart speakers you can buy in the UK” 
Last updated: 6 days ago
BestReviews
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Smart Speakers” 
Last updated: 4 days ago
Lustre.ai Logo

Built By the Slant team

Find the best product instantly.

Lustre recommends the best products at their lowest prices – right on Amazon.

4.7 star rating
Try it now - it's free
Lustre.ai illustration
undefinedurl nextprice drop