Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
Add Lustre to ChromeAdd Lustre to EdgeAdd Lustre to FirefoxAdd Lustre to OperaAdd Lustre to BraveAdd Lustre to Safari
•  100% Free
Loading
Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L
other_canonical
$139.95
Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag
Store Icon
amazon
$43.99
Vetted.ai LogoBy Slant
See Top Ranked Gym Bags

Herschel Novel Duffel Bag vs Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag

Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L

Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 20.5", 42.5L

Excellent
divein.com: Runner Up
Reddit: Loved
See our analysis
other_canonical
$139.95
Store Icon
amazon
See Price

Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag

Low/no data
The Spruce: Best Duffel
BestAdvisor: Runner Up
elle.com: Best Carry-On Garment Bag
See our analysis
Store Icon
amazon
$43.99
Analysis:

The Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L is an exemplary product and one of the very best Gym Bags at the $190 budget.

The Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag, however, doesn't seem to have enough data available for us to be able to draw any meaningful conclusions. If you're considering Gym Bags in the $40 range, you might want to check out some other options.

The Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L has done really well in a number of roundups conducted by sources that perform their own hands-on testing, such as Gear Patrol, Good Housekeeping, divein.com, and The Spruce - it was awarded the "BEST CLASSIC CANVAS GYM BAG" title by Gear Patrol, "Best Overnight Bag on Amazon" by Good Housekeeping, and "Ranked 2 out of 27" by divein.com. That's high praise from reliable sources.

As for the Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag - it impressed reviewers at The Spruce, a trustworthy source that conducts solid hands-on testing. It did great in its "The 9 Best Garment Bags of 2023" roundup - in fact, it earned its "Best Duffel" title, which, on its own, indicates a certain level of quality.

Comparison of expert ratings
Highly Recommended
Recommended
Mentioned
—Not Mentioned
divein.com
Good Housekeeping
Gear Patrol
The Spruce
esquire.com
menshealth.com
BestProducts.com
Gadget Review
refinery29.com
glamour.com
Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L
$139
9.6
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag
$43
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
—
Tech. Specs Comparison
Herschel Novel Duffel Bag, 13.5", 33L
$139
Convertible Garment Bag with Toiletry Bag
$43
Capacity
33 (L)
-
Gender
Unisex
-
Gym Bag Style
Duffle
-
Weight
0 (lb)
-
Reddit Threads (10)
r/xxfitness
in "Christmas Gift Megathread!"
Last updated: 9 Dec 2019
r/churning
in "Weekly Anything Goes Thread - Week of July 22, 2019"
Last updated: 22 Jul 2019
r/malefashionadvice
in "Quest for the Perfect Gym Bag"
Last updated: 17 May 2019
r/femalefashionadvice
in "Recent Purchases - February 04, 2019"
Last updated: 4 Feb 2019
r/Harley
in "First overnighter with the new sissy bar/luggage rack. Winters in CA are rough."
Last updated: 3 Feb 2019
r/malefashionadvice
in "I made a weekender bag in burgundy veg tanned calf"
Last updated: 21 Jan 2019
r/ManyBaggers
in "Gym bag that can double as a stylish weekend bag?"
Last updated: 2 Aug 2018
r/frugalmalefashion
in "Herschel Novel Duffel Bag $54.42 (Nordstrom)"
Last updated: 3 Oct 2019
r/malefashionadvice
in "Weekender bag with shoe compartment (build process)"
Last updated: 28 Jul 2019
r/malefashionadvice
in "(Advice Request) Let's settle the duffel debate."
Last updated: 15 Oct 2018
See morefewer
Reddit Threads (0)
—
No Data
Excellent expert review scores
9.6
Avg. Review Score
Score
divein.com
9.6
Has no expert reviews
—
No Data
Recommended by trusted experts
divein.com
Trusted Source
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “21 Best Gym Bags of 2023” 
Last updated: 9 May 2023
Good Housekeeping
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “9 Best Duffel Bags for Your Next Vacation, According to Testing” 
Last updated: 15 Oct 2022
Gear Patrol
Trusted Source
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
BEST CLASSIC CANVAS GYM BAG
in “The Best Gym Bags to Keep Your Training Goals In-Tote” 
Last updated: 17 Mar 2023
esquire.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The 21 Best Duffel Bags That Can Haul Everything, Everywhere” 
Last updated: 19 Jan 2023
menshealth.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Most popular duffel bag
in “The 22 Best Duffel Bags for Men to Haul Anywhere” 
Last updated: 10 Mar 2023
BestProducts.com
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
For the Best Man Who’s Always on the Move
in “20 Best-Man Gifts That Any Guy Would Be Stoked About” 
Last updated: 18 May 2022
Gadget Review
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #5 out of 10
in “Best Bags in 2023 (June Reviews)” 
Last updated: 24 Jan 2023
refinery29.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 19
in “19 Travel-Ready Duffel Bags That Even Over-Packers Will Love” 
Last updated: a month ago
glamour.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #45 out of 63
in “63 Best Amazon Gifts for Men (That They’ll Actually Want)” 
Last updated: a month ago
spy.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Duffel Bags on Amazon for Work, Play and Travel in 2022” 
Last updated: 23 Sep 2022
improb.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The 50 Best Weekender Duffel Bags for Men” 
Last updated: 30 Nov 2020
askmen.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Best Gym Bags for Men” 
Last updated: 26 Feb 2020
topdust.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “10 Best Weekender Bags” 
Last updated: 29 Aug 2019
tripononline.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The 10 Best Weekender Bags For Men For Every Trip” 
Last updated: 22 Mar 2023
alltopratings.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “Top 10 Best Duffle Bags in 2023 Reviews” 
Last updated: 16 Jan 2023
gearhungry.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “Best Duffel Bags in 2022” 
Last updated: 3 Jun 2022
faveable.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “33 Best Christmas Gifts For Men (2021)” 
Last updated: 3 Feb 2021
cosmopolitan.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
best for day trips
in “You’re Looking at the 17 Best Luggage Brands of 2023, Based on Reviews” 
Last updated: 9 days ago
harpersbazaar.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Duffel Gift
in “75 Amazon Gifts for Men That Will Instantly Impress Him” 
Last updated: 23 days ago
shopsitesee.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best weatherproof weekender bag
in “16 Best Weekender Bags for 2023” 
Last updated: 12 Apr 2023
one37pm.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Daily Duffel
in “The 25 Best Duffel Bags For Men at Every Price Point” 
kalibrado.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #3 out of 34
in “34 Best Duffel Bags and Weekenders for Men” 
Last updated: 14 Feb 2022
omnicoreagency.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #5 out of 13
in “The 14 Best Duffel Bags & Weekenders for Men in 2023” 
Last updated: a month ago
nextluxury.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #5 out of 13
in “Top 15 Best Gym Bags For Men - Carry Your Aethletic Appetite - Next Luxury” 
Last updated: 3 Jul 2022
thecoolist.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 23
in “24 Best Weekender Bags for Men; Going Far, Wide, and Deep” 
Last updated: 10 Jun 2022
divein.com
Trusted Source
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “10 Best Weekender Bags for Women & Men in 2022” 
Last updated: 3 Mar 2023
Good Housekeeping
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overnight Bag on Amazon
in “The Best Luggage on Amazon, According to Experts” 
Last updated: 13 Nov 2022
esquire.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Duffel Bag for College Students
in “The 28 Best Gifts for College Students That They Can Actually Use” 
Last updated: 19 days ago
menshealth.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Most versatile gym bag
in “The 15 Best Gym Bags for Men That Can Carry All Your Gear” 
Last updated: 7 Nov 2022
Gadget Review
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 7
in “Best Weekender Bag for Men” 
Last updated: 24 Jan 2023
spy.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #4 out of 10
in “10 Best Gym Duffle Bags on Amazon in 2022” 
Last updated: 31 Oct 2022
cosmopolitan.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 20
in “62 Best Gifts for Husbands and Partners Who Deserve the Freaking World” 
Last updated: 2 days ago
kalibrado.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 21
in “21 Best Gym Bags for Men” 
Last updated: 12 Nov 2021
thecoolist.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #13 out of 23
in “The 23 Best Gym Bags for Packing Your Pump To Go” 
Last updated: 19 May 2022
one37pm.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #28 out of 45
in “The 45 Best Gifts For College Students” 
esquire.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best gift for dad with a weekend plan
in “The 56 Best Father's Day Gifts You Can Dig Up on Amazon” 
Last updated: 19 days ago
Gadget Review
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #6 out of 10
in “10 Best Gym Bags in 2023” 
Last updated: 24 Jan 2023
spy.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 20
in “Top 20 Christmas Gifts for Men on Amazon in 2022” 
Last updated: 8 Feb 2022
esquire.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #3 out of 16
in “The 15 Coolest New Menswear Picks You Should Scoop This Week” 
Last updated: 6 Feb 2023
spy.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #17 out of 33
in “The 33 Best Gifts for Sneakerheads in 2022” 
Last updated: 13 Sep 2022
esquire.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 20
in “69 Best Amazon Gifts for Men That Are Actually Great” 
Last updated: 8 days ago
The Spruce
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 30 Best High School Graduation Gifts of 2023” 
Last updated: 17 Apr 2023
GQ
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Plus 13 More Gym Bags We Love” 
Last updated: 23 Oct 2017
usatoday.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Weekender Bags of 2023” 
Last updated: 19 days ago
prevention.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “24 Best Weekender Bags That Will Fit All of Your Essentials” 
Last updated: 4 May 2023
byrdie.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “15 Best Weekender Bags for Optimal Travel Ease” 
Last updated: 3 May 2023
werd.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 12 Best Men’s Weekender Duffle Bags for Quick Trips” 
Last updated: 8 Mar 2023
bobvila.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Travel Bags for Your Next Trip” 
Last updated: 19 Mar 2021
The Manual
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 7 Best Designer Bags Under $500 To Buy on Amazon in 2022” 
Last updated: 6 Feb 2021
gearmoose.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “20 Best Gym Bags For Men” 
Last updated: 8 Nov 2019
Gear Patrol
Trusted Source
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Duffle Bags for Those Dedicated to Travel” 
Last updated: 17 days ago
improb.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 18 Best Gym Bags for Men” 
Last updated: 12 Jun 2019
spy.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “9 Best Travel Bags of 2023: Carry-On, Duffle, Expandable Backpack” 
Last updated: 9 Jan 2023
See more recommendationsfewer recommendations
Recommended by trusted experts
The Spruce
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Duffel
in “The 9 Best Garment Bags of 2023” 
Last updated: 13 days ago
BestAdvisor
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “Best Luggage Bags for Suits” 
Last updated: 26 Feb 2023
elle.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Carry-On Garment Bag
in “The 10 Best Garment Bags for Travel and Storage” 
Last updated: 27 Apr 2023
Gadget Review
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #3 out of 6
in “Best Garment Bag” 
Last updated: 9 days ago
refinery29.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 26
in “The 26 Best Amazon Luggage, According To Frequent Travelers” 
Last updated: 10 days ago
travelandleisure.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “These Travel Bags Have 1 Genius Feature in Common to Keep Your Clothes Wrinkle-free” 
Last updated: 30 Apr 2023
theadventurelab.com.au
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Adventure Lab” 
Last updated: 14 Jul 2022
travellersworldwide.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The 7 Best Travel Garment Bags in 2023 | Travellers 🧳” 
Last updated: 6 Dec 2022
momjunction.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best With Pockets
in “15 Best Travel Garment Bags For Your Suits And Shirts In 2023” 
Last updated: 8 Feb 2023
tripsavvy.com
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Best Foldable
in “The 9 Best Travel Garment Bags of 2023” 
Last updated: 28 Sep 2022
planettravelerusa.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #5 out of 15
in “Best Suitcases for Suits in 2022 (Reviews & Buyer’s Guide)” 
Last updated: 14 Dec 2021
gearhungry.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #8 out of 14
in “Best Garment Bags In 2022” 
Last updated: 6 Jan 2023
kitcheninfinity.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 13
in “Best Carry On Luggage For Frequent Travelers” 
Last updated: 12 Apr 2023
luggage.travel
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 10 Best Travel Garment Bag” 
Last updated: 22 Apr 2020
chasingthedonkey.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Carry On Garment Bags” 
Last updated: 24 Mar 2023
The Manual
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 8 Best Luggage Pieces Under $50 for Men on Amazon” 
Last updated: 23 Jul 2021
mytrailco.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Top 20 Best Travel Garment Bag 2021 Review [New] MyTrail” 
Last updated: 5 Jan 2021
travelandleisure.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 12 Best Garment Bags for Wrinkle-free Travel in 2023” 
Last updated: a month ago
chasingthedonkey.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Carry On Garment Bags” 
Last updated: 24 Mar 2023
travelandleisure.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 15 Best Weekender Bags for Men in 2023” 
Last updated: 21 Apr 2023
chasingthedonkey.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Carry On Garment Bag Reviews” 
Last updated: 24 Mar 2023
See more recommendationsfewer recommendations
© Vetted Inc. 2023  •  Privacy Policy  •  Terms of Service  •  Jobs  •  Contact

Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
Add Lustre to ChromeAdd Lustre to EdgeAdd Lustre to FirefoxAdd Lustre to OperaAdd Lustre to BraveAdd Lustre to Safari
•  100% Free
undefinedurl nextprice drop