Heavy-Duty Boot Tray vs Ottomanson Multi-Purpose Indoor & Outdoor Waterproof Tray (30” x 15”)

We couldn't find enough data on either option to be able to come to any reliable conclusions. We strongly suggest that you look at some alternatives that also cost around $20.

The Heavy-Duty Boot Tray was loved by reviewers at Popular Mechanics, a trustworthy source that performs objective hands-on testing. It did great in their "8 Best Boot Trays to Keep Your Entryway Clean" roundup - in fact, they named it their "Best Heavy-Duty". That, by itself, points toward it being a noteworthy Boot Tray.

Moving on to the Ottomanson Multi-Purpose Indoor & Outdoor Waterproof Tray (30” x 15”): no sources that perform reliable and objective hands-on testing have included it in their Boot Tray roundups, which usually means that a product doesn't make for a good purchase.

As a last step, we wanted to do a head-to-head Heavy-Duty Boot Tray vs. Ottomanson Multi-Purpose Indoor & Outdoor Waterproof Tray (30” x 15”) comparison of their review performance but, unfortunately, weren't able to find any review ratings on either product.