Find the best product instantly

Loading
Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz)
Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz)
See Top Ranked Traditional Water Bottles

Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle vs Nalgene Wide Mouth Water Bottle

Analysis:

The Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz) and Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz) make for very strong choices and are great Traditional Water Bottles for their respective $19 and $11 asking prices. Depending on how much you're willing to spend, either of these options will serve you well.

Two highly trusted sources that perform well-thought-out in-depth testing consider the Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz) to be a great product - it earned the "Best Value for an Insulated Bottle" title from OutdoorGearLab and "Stainless Insulation at an Affordable Price" from BabyGearLab in their respective Traditional Water Bottle roundups, which is a good indication of it being a notable product.

As for the Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz), it was really well-received by reviewers at OutdoorGearLab, a reliable source that's known for conducting its own, high-quality, in-depth testing. It performed great in its "The Best Water Bottles of 2020" roundup and was named its "Best Bang for the Buck", which, on its own, makes it a product that warrants a closer look.

We conducted an analysis of all of the review data that we could find on these two products. First, we focused on sources that tested and rated both of them, like OutdoorGearLab, and learned that they all showed a preference for the Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz).

Then we took a look at the highest review scores that these two Traditional Water Bottles received. We found that the Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz) managed to earn a rating of 6.8 from OutdoorGearLab, whereas the Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz) got its highest, 7.6, score from reviewers at OutdoorGearLab.

Lastly, we averaged out all of the reviews scores that we could find on these two products and compared them to other Traditional Water Bottles on the market. We learned that both of them performed far better than most of their competitors - the overall review average earned by Traditional Water Bottles being 6.4 out of 10, whereas the Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz) and Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz) managed averages of 6.8 and 7.6 points, respectively.

Due to the difference in their prices, however, it's important to keep in mind that a direct Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz) vs. Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz) comparison might not be entirely fair - some sources don't take value for money into account when assigning their scores and therefore have a tendency to rate more premium products better.

Comparison of expert ratings
Highly Recommended
Recommended
Mentioned
Not Mentioned
OutdoorGearLab
BabyGearLab
Wirecutter
Reviewed
BestReviews
nytimes.com
Reddit
Tech. Specs Comparison
Simple Modern Summit Water Bottle (22 Oz)
$19
Nalgene Wide Mouth Silo Water Bottle (48 Oz)
$11
Has average expert review score
6.5
Overall Avg. for Traditional Water Bottles
6.8
Avg. Review Score
Score
Higher than average expert review score
6.5
Overall Avg. for Traditional Water Bottles
7.6
Avg. Review Score
Score
Highly recommended by trusted experts
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Value for an Insulated Bottle
in “The Best Water Bottles of 2020” 
Last updated: 20 days ago
BabyGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Stainless Insulation at an Affordable Price
in “The Best Kids Water Bottle” 
Last updated: 9 Mar 2020
Wirecutter
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The 8 Best Water Bottles” 
Last updated: 27 Mar 2020
Wirecutter
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Growler” 
Last updated: 20 Feb 2020
nytimes.com
-
Depth of
analysis
No
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Growler” 
Last updated: 20 Feb 2020
Wirecutter
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “The Best Kids Water Bottles” 
Last updated: 5 Aug 2019
Recommended by trusted experts
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Bang for the Buck
in “The Best Water Bottles of 2020” 
Last updated: 20 days ago
Reviewed
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #16 out of 17
in “The Best Water Bottles of 2020” 
Last updated: a month ago
Lustre.ai Logo

Built By the Slant team

Find the best product instantly.

Lustre recommends the best products at their lowest prices – right on Amazon.

4.7 star rating
Try it now - it's free
Lustre.ai illustration
undefinedurl nextprice drop