Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
Add Lustre to Chrome
•  100% Free
Loading
Orca 58-Qt Cooler
Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler
See Top Ranked Hard Coolers

Orca Hard Cooler vs Coleman Xtreme Marine Cooler

Analysis:

The Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler and Orca 58-Qt Cooler make for good, if unremarkable, Hard Coolers at their respective budgets.

With that said, while they both should serve reasonably well, you might want to look into other options at the $60 and $330 price points - it's likely that there are some better alternatives available.

If you want to learn more about the Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler and the Orca 58-Qt Cooler, however, we prepared a summary of the information that we have:

The Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler has managed to impress reviewers from some of the most highly trusted sources on the internet, including Wirecutter (NYTimes) and OutdoorGearLab. It performed great in their in-depth hands-on roundups - it was awarded the "Top Pick" title by Wirecutter (NYTimes) and "Best on a Tight Budget" by OutdoorGearLab in their respective Hard Cooler roundups. That's high praise, especially when coming from such high-quality sources.

As for the Orca 58-Qt Cooler - it was really well-received by reviewers at OutdoorGearLab, a great source that's known for conducting high-quality in-depth testing. It performed great in its "The Best Coolers of 2020" roundup and was named its "Ranked 2 out of 16", which, on its own, makes it a product that warrants a closer look.

We conducted an analysis of all of the review data that we could find on these two products. First, we focused on sources that tested and rated both of them, like CNET and OutdoorGearLab, and learned that they all showed a preference for the Orca 58-Qt Cooler.

Then we took a look at the highest review scores that these two Hard Coolers received. We found that the Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler managed to earn a rating of 7 from CNET, whereas the Orca 58-Qt Cooler got its highest, 8.1, score from reviewers at CNET.

Lastly, in order to better compare them to the rest of their competition, we averaged out their review scores. The Orca 58-Qt Cooler managed to get 7.9 out of 10 - considerably better than the 6.1 review average of Hard Coolers in general - whereas the Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler earned 6.0 points.

It should be said that doing a direct Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler vs. Orca 58-Qt Cooler comparison might not be entirely fair due to the difference in their prices - some sources don't put much weight on value for money and thus tend to give better review scores to more expensive products.

Comparison of expert ratings
Highly Recommended
Recommended
Mentioned
Not Mentioned
OutdoorGearLab
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
CNET
BestReviews
Reddit
YouTube
Tech. Specs Comparison
Orca 58-Qt Cooler
$339
Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler
$47
Capacity
58 (qt)
70 (qt)
Ice Retention
10 (days)
5 (days)
Weight
36 (lb)
13.4 (lb)
Sentiment analysis from Youtube reviewers
No Data
Significantly higher than average expert review score
6.2
Overall Avg. for Hard Coolers
8.0
Avg. Review Score
Score
Has average expert review score
6.2
Overall Avg. for Hard Coolers
6.0
Avg. Review Score
Score
Recommended by trusted experts
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Runner Up
in “The Best Coolers of 2020” 
Last updated: 2 days ago
BestReviews
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Coolers” 
Last updated: 3 days ago
Highly recommended by trusted experts
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Great Gear for Picnics and Grilling” 
Last updated: 20 days ago
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best on a Tight Budget
in “The Best Coolers of 2020” 
Last updated: 2 days ago
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Coolers” 
Last updated: 27 Apr 2020
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Gear for Your Road Trips” 
Last updated: 24 Apr 2020
BestReviews
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Coleman Coolers” 
Last updated: 3 days ago

Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
Add Lustre to Chrome
•  100% Free
undefinedurl nextprice drop