Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
Loading
Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler
Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt
See Top Ranked Hard Coolers

Coleman Xtreme Marine Cooler vs Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler

Analysis:

The Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler has impressed reviewers from two sources that are among the most highly trusted on the internet, namely Wirecutter (NYTimes) and OutdoorGearLab. It did great in their objective hands-on roundups - it earned the "Top Pick" and "Best on a Tight Budget" awards from Wirecutter (NYTimes) and OutdoorGearLab, respectively. That's high praise from such reputable sources.

As for the Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt - it was really well-received by reviewers at Tom's Guide, a great source that's known for conducting high-quality in-depth testing. It performed great in its "The best coolers in 2021" roundup and was named its "The best cooler for outdoorsy types", which, on its own, makes it a product that warrants a closer look.

We examined all of the review data that we could find and first took a look at sources that reviewed both of them, like OutdoorGearLab, and found that they haven't shown a preference for either product.

Then we checked which sources liked these two Hard Coolers best and found that the Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler got its highest, 8, review score from reviewers at OutdoorGearLab, whereas the Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt earned its best score of 8 from OutdoorGearLab.

Lastly, we averaged out all of the reviews scores that we could find on these two products and compared them to other Hard Coolers on the market. We learned that both of them performed far better than most of their competitors - the overall review average earned by Hard Coolers being 6.1 out of 10, whereas the Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler and Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt managed averages of 6.8 and 8.0 points, respectively.

Due to the difference in their prices, however, it's important to keep in mind that a direct Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler vs. Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt comparison might not be entirely fair - some sources don't take value for money into account when assigning their scores and therefore have a tendency to rate more premium products better.

Comparison of expert ratings
Highly Recommended
Recommended
Mentioned
Not Mentioned
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
OutdoorGearLab
Tom's Guide
CleverHiker
Switchback Travel
Android Central
Epicurious
foodandwine.com
BestReviews
topratedcooler.com
Tech. Specs Comparison
Coleman 70 qt. Xtreme Marine Cooler
$58
Pelican Elite Wheeled Cooler 55-Qt
Capacity
70 (qt)
-
Ice Retention
5 (days)
-
Weight
13.4 (lb)
-
Sentiment analysis from Youtube reviewers
No Data
Higher than average expert review score
6.2
Overall Avg. for Hard Coolers
6.8
Avg. Review Score
Score
Significantly higher than average expert review score
6.2
Overall Avg. for Hard Coolers
8.0
Avg. Review Score
Score
Highly recommended by trusted experts
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Beach and Surf Gear: Umbrellas, Chairs, Beginner Surfboards, and More” 
Last updated: 25 Jun 2021
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best on a Tight Budget
in “Best Cooler of 2021” 
Last updated: 9 days ago
Tom's Guide
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #9 out of 9
in “The best coolers in 2021” 
Last updated: 3 days ago
CleverHiker
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “10 Best Coolers of 2021” 
Switchback Travel
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Budget Cooler
in “Best Coolers and Ice Chests of 2021” 
Last updated: 20 Aug 2021
Android Central
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Heavy-Duty
in “Best Coolers for Summer in 2021” 
Last updated: 5 Dec 2020
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Gear for Your Road Trips” 
Last updated: 7 Jun 2021
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “The Best Coolers” 
Last updated: 30 Apr 2021
Wirecutter (NYTimes)
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Best Overall
in “Great Gear for Picnics and Grilling” 
Last updated: 26 Jun 2020
BestReviews
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Coolers” 
Last updated: 20 Aug 2021
BestReviews
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Mentioned
in “Best Coleman Coolers” 
Last updated: 20 May 2021
Recommended by trusted experts
Tom's Guide
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
The best cooler for outdoorsy types
in “The best coolers in 2021” 
Last updated: 3 days ago
OutdoorGearLab
Highly Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Rated 8.0 out of 10
in “Best Cooler of 2021” 
Last updated: 9 days ago
Switchback Travel
Trusted Source
Depth of
analysis
Yes
In-house
Testing
Ranked #12 out of 14
in “Best Coolers and Ice Chests of 2021” 
Last updated: 20 Aug 2021

Find the best product and price, effortlessly.

Discover deals on products actually worth buyingthe best products

We do the research. You save the money.
undefinedurl nextprice drop