The Backyard Homestead by Carleen Madigan vs Vertical Gardening

We couldn't find enough data on either option to be able to come to any reliable conclusions. We strongly suggest that you look at some alternatives that also cost around $12.

No sources that perform objective hands-on testing have deemed the The Backyard Homestead by Carleen Madigan worthy of being included in their Gardening Book roundups, which typically isn't a good sign.

As for the Vertical Gardening - it impressed reviewers at The Spruce, a trustworthy source that conducts solid hands-on testing. It did great in its "The 11 Best Gardening Books of 2023" roundup - in fact, it earned its "Best for Vertical Gardening" title, which, on its own, indicates a certain level of quality.

As a last step, we wanted to do a head-to-head The Backyard Homestead by Carleen Madigan vs. Vertical Gardening comparison of their review performance but, unfortunately, weren't able to find any review ratings on either product.