Muck Boot Muckster ll Women's Rubber Garden Shoes vs Women's Mid Calf Rain Boots

The Muck Boot Muckster ll Women's Rubber Garden Shoes is widely considered to be a great Gardening Shoe at its $40 budget. The Women's Mid Calf Rain Boots, however, while also a good product at this price point, doesn't stack up against its competitors quite as well.

The Muck Boot Muckster ll Women's Rubber Garden Shoes was loved by reviewers at Good Housekeeping, a trustworthy source that performs objective hands-on testing. It did great in their "15 Best Waterproof Shoes for Women, According to Shoe Experts" roundup - in fact, they named it their "Best Waterproof Shoes for Gardening". That, by itself, points toward it being a noteworthy Gardening Shoe.

Taking a look at the Women's Mid Calf Rain Boots, we found that it hasn't managed to perform well enough to earn a spot in any Gardening Shoe roundups done by sources that conduct their own, high-quality, hands-on testing. That alone makes it difficult to recommend.

As a last step, we wanted to do a head-to-head Muck Boot Muckster ll Women's Rubber Garden Shoes vs. Women's Mid Calf Rain Boots comparison of their review performance but, unfortunately, weren't able to find any review ratings on either product.