17 best alternatives to Osprey Comet as of 2018 - Slant

Osprey Farpoint 40

Top Pro

Extremely durable

Osprey is known for creating long-lasting, strong and well designed packs. See More

Top Con

Laptop compartment located at the front

Because the laptop compartment is located at the front of the pack rather than against your back, it can make the bag feel heavier. The laptop compartment can also curve if you pack is full, which can cause the laptop screen to crack. See More

Top Pro

Available in two torso lengths

The pack is available in two torso lengths. Small/Medium, which is more suitable for shorter women, and Medium/Large. See More

Top Con

Limited number of pockets

There isn't much in the way of pockets for organization. There are small mesh pockets inside the main compartment, and one external pocket for papers and such. See More

Top Pro

Fits up to a 17" laptop

The separate laptop compartment fits up to a 17" laptop. See More

Specs

Weight:S/M = 3.11 lbs M/L = 3.17 lbs

Dimensions:S/M = 20 x 14 x 9 in M/L = 22 x 14 x 9 in

Capacity:S/M = 38L M/L = 40L

13 0

Osprey Porter 30

Top Con

Only one external pocket

The only external pocket is the front panel organizational compartment for papers, tablets and a laptop. There are no pockets for food or anything else you may want quick access to. See More

Top Pro

Padded carry handles

There are two padded grab handles, one at the top and the other at the side. See More

Top Con

Minimal support makes it uncomfortable to wear for long periods

The padding on both the shoulder straps and hip belt is quite light. Especially when heavy, the straps can dig into your shoulders and become uncomfortable. See More

Top Pro

Attachments for a daypack

Reinforced loops allow you to attach a daypack to the front of the Porter (designed specifically for the Daylite Pack). See More

Top Con

No internal compression straps

There are no straps in the main compartment to help secure your belongings, so they may shift while traveling. See More

Top Pro

Stowaway harness

They quickly hide away in a zippered pouch to protect that harness when stowed, or to keep them out of the way when navigating tight places. See More

Specs

Weight:2.49 lbs

Dimensions:21 x 15 x 11 in

See All Experiences

4 0

Tortuga Travel Backpack

Top Pro

Lockable zippers for security

The zippers on the main compartment are lockable to help keep your belongings safe. See More

Top Con

Unattractive design

The Tortuga is only available in one color and has a boxy shape that some people find unattractive. See More

Top Pro

Front pockets for quick access

There are two zippered pockets on the hip belt for easy access to money, tickets, etc.. See More

Top Con

Not great for shorter people

The torso fit for the Tortuga is 18"+, there is currently no version available for those with a shorter torso. See More

Top Pro

Extremely durable

This pack can be taken on year-long trips around the world. It can face an unimaginable number of different environments and take a huge amount of abuse. After all that, it can still be used actively and works just as well as a new bag. See More

Top Pro

Can handle larger laptops

The separate laptop compartment fits up to a 17" laptop. See More

Top Pro

Easily fits under seats

The boxy design of the Tortuga means it can be easily stored under train or bus seats while traveling. See More

Top Pro

Two carry handles for navigating busy areas

There are two padded carry handles, one at the top and another at the side. This makes it easy to carry the pack when you're navigating a tight place, like cramped aisles or busy subways. See More

Specs

Weight:3.65 lbs

Dimensions:2 x 14 x 9 in

Torso Fit:18+ in.

See All Experiences

16 0

Kelty Women's Redwing 40

Top Pro

Beautiful design

Travel backpacks aren't exactly known for their beauty. However, appearance was a consideration when the Redwing was designed, and it shows. See More

Top Con

No laptop compartment

There is no compartment specifically designed for a laptop, so the only option is putting it in the main compartment. See More

Top Pro

Lots of external storage

The Redwing 40 has loops at the front for hanging things off of, and mesh pockets for holding anything that may need to dry out. It has large pockets on both sides for water bottles, and a compartment at the front with lots of internal pockets for organizing. See More

Top Con

Carry strap isn't padded

There is only one carry strap, located at the top of the pack. It's a fairly thin strip of material and quickly becomes uncomfortable to hold, especially when the pack is heavy. See More

Top Pro

Front or top loading

You can either use this pack as a top-load, or a front load. See More

Top Con

Better suited for use with packing cubes/bags

There are no internal straps in the main apartment to keep clothes from moving around. And due to the fact the top of the pack zips away, you are left with the main compartment having 3 walls instead of 4 when unzipped. Combined, it's hard to keep your clothes and other belongings where you want them if not using bags or packing cubes. See More

Top Pro

Hydration compatible

Top Pro

Very comfortable

Specs

Weight:2 lbs 10 oz

Dimensions:23 x 14 x 12 in

Torso fit:14.5 - 18.5 in

See All Experiences

12 0

REI Trail 40 Pack

Top Pro

Women-specific version available

There is a women-specific version of the REI Trail 40 available, which has a slightly smaller torso fit range. See More

Top Con

Pocket for hydration reservoir is difficult to access

The pocket for the hydration reservoir is external, located right behind the back panel. There is very little room, making it hard to access and can only fit a small amount of water (around 1.5L). See More

Top Pro

Pockets on the hip belt for easy access

The hip belt has two zippered pockets which lets you store things for easy access (such as papers, money or snacks). See More

Top Con

Internal bungee compression system can get in the way

The internal compression straps are a bungee system, which does not unclip the way most do. When your pack is full, this can make it a very tight squeeze if you want to access something in the back. See More

Top Pro

Four zipper access to easily get to your belongings

The pack is front load with four zipper access, allowing you to unzip from either the top or bottom. This is great if you want to grab something from the bottom of your pack without opening it completely. See More

Top Pro

Includes raincover

The pack comes with a rain cover that stows away in it's own zip pocket. See More

Specs

Weight:2 lbs. 14 oz.

Dimensions:21.625 x 13.125 x 10.5 in

Torso fit:M = 17 - 19 in; L = 18 - 20 in

See All Experiences

9 0

Gregory J38

Top Pro

Women-specific fit

The suspension system and harness is designed specifically for women. The torso fit has a range suitable for shorter backpackers as well. See More

Top Con

Not specifically designed for travel

The J38 is a versatile pack, but not specifically designed for travel. It has some features you may not have a use for (such a pole loops) and is lacking in features you may find helpful (like a laptop sleeve). The shape is not ideal for storage (under seats, or in the overhead). See More

Top Pro

Integrated rain cover

The pack includes a color-matched, quick-attach rain cover. See More

Top Con

Expensive

Compared to other packs around this size, the price tag on the Gregory is a bit higher. See More

Top Pro

Very well built

Gregory is known for their very durable and well designed bags. See More

Specs

Weight:S = 2 lbs 12 oz M = 2 lbs 15 oz

Capacity:S = 38L M = 40L

Torso fit:S = 16 - 18 in M = 18 - 20 in

Torso Fit:S = 16 - 18 in M = 18 - 20 in

3 0

REI Trail 40 Pack - Women's

Top Pro

Includes raincover

The pack comes with a rain cover that stows away in it's own zip pocket. See More

Top Con

Pocket for hydration reservoir is difficult to access

The pocket for the hydration reservoir is external, located right behind the back panel. There is very little room, making it hard to access and can only fit a small amount of water (around 1.5L). See More

Top Pro

Four zipper access to easily get to your belongings

The pack is front load with four zipper access, allowing you to unzip from either the top or bottom. This is great if you want to grab something from the bottom of your pack without opening it completely. See More

Top Con

Internal bungee compression system can get in the way

The internal compression straps are a bungee system, which does not unclip the way most do. When your pack is full, this can make it a very tight squeeze if you want to access something in the back. See More

Top Pro

Pockets on the hip belt for easy access

The hip belt has two zippered pockets which lets you store things for easy access (such as papers, money or snacks). See More

Specs

Weight:2 lbs. 13 oz.

Dimensions:S = 20.25 x 13.125 x 10.5 in M = 21.6 x 13 x 10.5 in

Torso Fit:S = 16 - 18 in M = 17 - 19 in

5 0

Pacsafe Venturesafe 45L

Top Pro

Both compartments can be locked with the same lock

The Roobar design allows the zippers of both compartments to be locked with a single cable lock. See More

Top Con

Laptop compartment is at the front of the pack

Heavy items should be closest to your back. However with the laptop compartment located at the front of the pack, the weight can throw off your balance and make the bag feel heavier. See More

Top Pro

Anti-theft fabric

A stainless steel wire mesh is embedded in the fabric, making the pack much more difficult to cut open. See More

Top Con

Laptop compartment only unzips on one side

The laptop compartment only unzips on a single side, making it hard to access. See More

Top Pro

Stowaway straps

The shoulder straps and hip belt can be tucked behind the back panel. See More

Specs

Weight:3 lbs 7.4 oz

Dimensions:22 x 14 x 9.1 in

3 0

TLS Mother Lode Weekender Convertible

Top Pro

Lots of pockets

It's very easy to keep the pack organized thanks to all the pockets on both the inside and outside. See More

Top Con

Not water resistant

The material is not water resistant, so even a small amount of rain can get to your belongings. See More

Top Pro

Stowaway shoulder straps

The shoulder straps quickly zip into their own compartment, keeping them out of the way when storing or using as a duffle bag. See More

Top Con

Minimal waist strap

The waist strap is only a single strap with no padding, so it doesn't offer much support. See More

Top Pro

Variety of colors available

There is more choice than is usually available with travel packs. The TLS Mother Lode Weekender is available in 6 colors currently. See More

Top Pro

Can be carried as a duffle

It's a convertible pack, so you're not limited to wearing it only as a backpack. The bag includes a shoulder strap so can be carried as a duffle or a suitcase. See More

Top Pro

Lifetime Warranty

The bag has a lifetime warranty. See More

Specs

Weight:3 lbs 15 oz

Dimensions:22 x 14 x 9 in

See All Experiences

2 0

Help millions of people make better decisions.

Each month, over 2.8 million people use Slant to find the best products and share their knowledge. Pick the tags you’re passionate about to get a personalized feed and begin contributing your knowledge.