Commonly Compared
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Well supported
File-roller is the official gnome archive manager and used in other desktop environments too. The large user-base and active development have made it stable.
Cons
Con Can't preview 7Zip archives
File Roller (and Engrampa which was forked from File Roller) has to read the whole 7zip archive to show the content.