What is the best alternative to Masterbuilt Butterball MB23010618 XL Electric Fryer?

Question

Built By the Slant team

Find the best product instantly.

4.7 star rating

Try it now - it's free

score 2 · Answer 1

Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Turkey Fryer

Top Pro

Lots of healthy cooking possibilities

The fryer doesn't use any oil when cooking the turkey so the result is a more healthier meal. On top of that there are many accessories available for the fryer so you can use this fryer as a healthier method for cooking chicken wings, rib racks, kabobs and so on. See More

Top Con

Cooks slower compared to deep-fryers

Air fryers are generally slower than deep fat fryers. While usually a deep fryer take around 2-3 minutes per pound of turkey, an air fryer takes about 10 minutes to cook so expect around 2 or more hours for a 15 pound turkey. See More

Top Pro

Suited for large turkeys

The fryers can fry a turkey up to 16 pounds so you can cook a meal for a large family reunion. See More

Top Con

Not effective in cold weather

When the air temperature is cold or you have a lot of wind you may experience that the fryer can’t maintain heat to cook the turkey thoroughly. See More

Top Pro

Cheap accessories available

Char-Broil offers lots of cheap accessories to further expand the functionality of the fryer. You can buy rib hooks, a leg rack for chicken legs and wings, a kabob holder set for making kabob and a bunk bed basket that allows to bake more things simultaneously. See More

Top Con

Not everyone likes the taste

Not everyone will like the taste of the meat since many prefer the crispiness that deep-frying provides. See More

Top Pro

Safe

There is no risk getting skin burns spilling hot oil on yourself when using this fryer. See More

Top Con

Can’t create a smoked flavor

There is no smoke box for wood chips so you can’t add a smoked flavor to your meal. See More

Top Pro

Saves money

Since you don’t have to fill it up with gallons of oil you save money in the long term. See More

Top Pro

Easy to clean

Since there is no grease involved cleanup is faster and easier than dealing with gallons of oil and the potential mess it can create. Also there is a removable drip pan located underneath the heating chamber, which catches dripping juices, allowing them to be used to make a homemade gravy. See More

Specs

Weight:35 lbs

Dimensions:20.8 x 23.5 x 16.3 inches

Warranty:90 days

Material:Stainless steel

See All Specs

See All Experiences

2 0

score 1 · Answer 2

Masterbuilt Butterball Oil-Free Electric Turkey Fryer and Roaster

Top Pro

Can be used indoors and outdoors

Since there isn’t any gas or oil involved you can safely use it outdoors and indoors. See More

Top Con

No accessories available

Masterbuilt doesn’t offer any additional accessories so you can’t expand the versatility of the fryer. See More

Top Pro

Can achieve a smoked flavor

Thanks to the wood chip pan you can add a smoked flavor to the meat. See More

Top Con

Slow

Expect about 10 minutes per pound cooking time compared to 2-3 minutes when using an oil fryer. See More

Top Pro

Safe to use

There is no hot oil involved that can potential catch fire or cause severe burns, so this fryer is safe to use and doesn’t require constant supervision. See More

Top Con

Short electricity cable

The cable is 4 feet long so it limits you without an extension cable. See More

Top Pro

Healthy cooking

Since there is no grease involved when frying, the cooked turkey is healthier and contains less calories compared to deep fried turkeys. See More

Top Con

Small capacity

While it theoretically can be used for turkey up to 18 pounds, the instructions recommend a turkey closer to 12 pounds. This is because a large turkey literally has to be stuffed into the unit and this can cause it to burn around the outside before the inside gets cooked. See More

Specs

Weight:28.4 lbs

Dimensions:16.7 x 16.7 x 17.3 inches

Warranty:90 days

Material:Stainless steel

See All Specs

See All Experiences

1 0