DevelopmentTesting

What are the best software tools for test management?

29
Options 
Considered
0
User 
Recs.
Last 
Updated

Klaros TestManagement vs TestCaseLab vs Meliora Testlab

 vs XQual XStudio vs SpiraTest vs Test Collab vs PractiTest vs QASymphony qTest vs TestLodge vs ReferTy S.A.S. ReferTest vs TestWave vs Testuff vs HP Quality Center vs Micro Focus QADirector vs TestCaseDB vs Catch Enterprise Tester vs Visual Studio Test Professional 2012 vs Andagon Aqua vs Zephyr vs TestCube vs Squash TM vs TeamTest TestLink vs Mozilla Testopia vs Gurock Software TestRail vs Tricentis Tosca Testsuite vs QMetry vs SmartBear QAComplete vs IBM Rational Quality Manager vs MicroFocus SilkCentral Test Manager

Specs

Platforms

Windows, Linux

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

$124/$149 monthly

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

$40/$48 monthly

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

$83/$99 monthly

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

$169/$199 monthly

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

$332/$399 monthly

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Platforms

-

Advanced (yearly/monthly) - 3000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Basic (yearly/monthly) - 500 test cases / unlimited users

-

Essential (yearly/monthly) - 1000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Ultimate (yearly/monthly) - 9 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Enterprise (yearly/monthly) - 50 000 test cases / unlimited users

-

Pros + Cons

Pro
 Free Community Edition available

A free, limited Community Edition of Klaros TestManagement is available. Notably, it lacks test documentation, project management, configuration capabilities. A full comparison can be found here.
Comment

Pro
 The customer service is very good

The people are always responsive and helpful.
Comment

Pro
 Free 30 day trial

For those that want to test out the full software there is a free trial of 30 days where users can see for themselves how it behaves.
Comment

Pro
 Execute your tests via a mobile device

Test steps can be taken via a mobile device.
Comment

Con
 No free version

Klaros TestManagement does not offer any free version, not even a free trial period.
Comment

Pro
 Unlimited users, pay only for test cases

Comment

Pro
 Clean UI

Has no needless clicks.
Comment

Pro
 Great support

The Testcaselab team hears suggestions and implement the features that users ask each month.
Comment

Pro
 Saves time

Allows doing less routine work comparing to the usual test case management methods (google/excel spreadsheets or the other tool).
Comment

Pro
 Integrations

Has integrations with commonly used tools (Redmine, Jira, Pivotal, YouTrack, Asana, Trello, Mantis).
Comment

Pro
 User friendly

Comment

Con
 No requirements management

Comment

Pro
 Detailed reports

Comment

Pro
 Cheap

Comment

Pro
 Supports a simple workflow to quickly start testing

If a project needs to get started with testing ASAP, Meliora Testlab allows users to get to that stage using a "simple workflow" which means that the project and the test cases don't need to be reviewed, simply add test cases and start testing.
Comment

Pro
 Jenkins integration

Meliora Testlab can run automated testing through Jenkins CI.
Comment

Pro
 Powerful team collaboration features

Meliora Test Lab has some powerful features which make team collaboration easy and painless. Things like assignments and real-time notifications help a lot when working with teams.
Comment

Con
 Dashboard configuration is not based on roles

Some configurations, including dashboard configuration are not based on roles, which means that each team member needs to setup the dashboard themselves.
Comment

Con
 Supports only one way integrations

Integrations with external systems (for example Jira) are only one-way. This means that while you can submit bugs which will be tracked by Jira, changes in Jira itself are not fed back to XStudio.
Comment

Pro
 Free community edition available

XStudio has a free comunity edition available for up to 4 users and 200 tests.
Comment

Pro
 Can interface with any automation framework, even proprietary

XQual provides more than 50 drivers to interface with all the automation tools in the market but also an SDK that gives the ability to develop ones own if they have a proprietary framework for instance.
Comment

Pro
 Nice design

The GUI is really nice and easy to use for a such complete product. Usually, when you have all those features (ability to drive automated tests, parametrization etc.) this becomes quickly messy. No problem here... it's very clean and nicely designed.
Comment

Pro
 Free plan

Comment

Pro
 Bug tracker integration

TestCollab enjoys full bi-directional integration with the most popular bug trackers.
Comment

Pro
 Test Automation support

Comment

Pro
 Bi-directional integration

Comment

Con
 No custom reports

TestCollab does not offer the option to create custom reports.
Comment

Pro
 Can either be self-hosted or hosted through a SaaS

TestCollab gives users flexibility in choosing their hosting method. They can either choose a self-hosted plan if they want to host the software on their servers or they can choose a hosted plan to host it on the cloud.
Comment

Pro
 Versioning and Reusability of test cases

Comment

Pro
 Supports agile methodologies

Comment

Pro
 Good integrations

Comment

Pro
 Works good with Jira

Comment

Pro
 Some nice features

Comment

Pro
 All necessary modules + exploratory testing which is very helpful

Comment

Con
 Takes a long time to understand how the system works

Comment

Pro
 Multiple users can execute tests independently on their own computer because the QTP scripts are stored in Quality Center which is web based. All test cases are stored in one location (Quality Center) which makes it easier for users to access and maintain.

Comment

Con
 When a particular version of Quality Center has reached end of life, the customer is forced to upgrade to the newer version to be eligible to get technical support. The upgrade process can be time intensive and requires a lot of planning.

Comment

Con
 No Mac OS X version

Comment
undefinedurl nextprice drop