What are the best crib mattresses around $400?

Question

3

Options
Considered

4

User
Recs.

Jan 25, 2018

Last
Updated

Here’s the Deal

3 Options Considered

Best crib mattresses around $400	Price	Weight	Dimensions (L x W x H)
-- Moonlight Slumber Starlight Supreme	$299	11.5 pounds	52 x 27.5 x 6 inches
-- Nook Pebble Pure	$395	25 pounds	53 x 28 x 4 inches
-- Naturalmat Coco Mat	$384	15.4 pounds	52 x 28 x 5.5 inches

See Full List

I Recommend...

Built By the Slant team

Find the best product instantly.

4.7 star rating

Try it now - it's free

score 2 · Answer 1

Moonlight Slumber Starlight Supreme

Top Pro

Supports your baby's proper bone development

The side of the mattress meant for toddlers' use has a cooling visco gel (or memory foam) that is ultra supportive. It conforms to your child's contours, supporting their growing bones and joints and keeping their spine in perfect alignment as they sleep. See More

Top Con

Makes noises that can wake the baby

The fabric cover makes a soft swoosh sound that may not be audible by the onlooking parents, but is loud enough to wake babies from their sleep. See More

Specs

Weight:11.5 pounds

Dimensions (L x W x H):52 x 27.5 x 6 inches

Top Pro

Ensures that babies breathe well during sleep

There are vertical 'tunnels' that let air rapidly pass from the surface through the mattress. This creates a more comfortable sleep environment in terms of temperature regulation and increased air circulation. See More

Top Pro

Fire-resistant

Covering the foam-core is a mineral-derived, non-toxic woven fire barrier that has not been sprayed with chemicals (common in other mattresses). This prevents flame and heat from catching on the mattress in case of a fire. See More

Top Pro

The cover is impenetrable by bedbugs and dust mites

The fabric cover is ultrasonically welded together, not sewn, for a cleaner and safer dust mite-resistant mattress. See More

Top Pro

A safe and clean place for babies to sleep in

Cleanliness is every parent's top-concern. This high-quality mattress has a fabric cover that is water, stain, and odor resistant. See More

See All

score 1 · Answer 2

Nook Pebble Pure

Top Pro

Safe and healthy sleep environment for your baby

The Pebble Pure is all-organic inside and out. Inside are 3 inches of coconut husk and natural latex foam while the fire barrier is made of organic wool. The cover is made of organic cotton. All Nook products are made with materials derived from the earth and the processes are non-toxic, ensuring that your babies are safe from toxic chemicals. See More

Top Con

Difficult to lift and move

Weighing 25 lbs, the Pebble Pure is heavy: this is due to the 3-inch thick coconut husk fibers inside. It is backbreaking to lift and move around when removing the zip-cover. This is also the reason why many parents choose not to put fitted sheets on top of the mattress cover. See More

Specs

Weight:25 pounds

Dimensions (L x W x H):53 x 28 x 4 inches

Top Pro

Maintains a clean surface for your baby to sleep on

Every Nook cover is liquid resistant. It does not stain and fluids can't seep through the fabric, preventing bacteria buildup on the surface. It also prevents moisture buildup inside, which can cause mold and mildew. See More

Top Pro

Does not require crib sheets that may bunch up and cause suffocation

The Pebble Pure is crib-ready; there is no need for mattress pads, covers or crib sheets. The zip-off cover is removable and can be washed regularly, which means you don't require an extra sheet. This eliminates the risk of suffocation caused by a loose sheet bunching and accidentally covering your baby's face. See More

Top Pro

Airflow eliminates the risk of suffocation and sudden infant death

The materials are all breathable and in case your baby tilts and accidentally sleeps flat on their stomach, they will still be able to breathe through the surface and not suffocate. See More

See All

score 1 · Answer 3

Naturalmat Coco Mat

Top Pro

All its materials promote good air circulation for breathability and temperature regulation

It is designed to be as airy, yet insulating, as possible. The coconut husks and cotton are breathable and the lambswool naturally helps regulate your baby’s body temperature. See More

Top Con

Not water-resistant

The cotton cover is not water and stain proof and Naturalmat requires you to buy an additional mattress cover to prevent stains and liquids from seeping into the fabric. See More

Specs

Weight:15.4 pounds

Dimensions (L x W x H):52 x 28 x 5.5 inches

Top Pro

Completely organic, from the materials to the manufacturing processes

The Coco Mat is made entirely with all-organic materials, from organic coconut fibers, organic lambswool, natural latex made from rubber sap to the organic cotton cover. See More

Top Pro

Naturally flame-resistant

The wool batting that covers the coconut husks meets USA federal and state fire safety standards since it is a flame retardant by itself; unlike those mattresses doused in toxic fire-retardant chemicals. See More

See All

The Slant team built an AI & it’s awesome

Find the best product instantly

What are the best crib mattresses around $400?

3 Options Considered

Moonlight Slumber Starlight Supreme

My Recommendation for Moonlight Slumber Starlight Supreme

My Recommendation for Moonlight Slumber Starlight Supreme

Supports your baby's proper bone development

Makes noises that can wake the baby

Ensures that babies breathe well during sleep

Fire-resistant

The cover is impenetrable by bedbugs and dust mites

A safe and clean place for babies to sleep in

Nook Pebble Pure

My Recommendation for Nook Pebble Pure

My Recommendation for Nook Pebble Pure

Safe and healthy sleep environment for your baby

Difficult to lift and move

Maintains a clean surface for your baby to sleep on

Does not require crib sheets that may bunch up and cause suffocation

Airflow eliminates the risk of suffocation and sudden infant death

Naturalmat Coco Mat

My Recommendation for Naturalmat Coco Mat

My Recommendation for Naturalmat Coco Mat

All its materials promote good air circulation for breathability and temperature regulation

Not water-resistant

Completely organic, from the materials to the manufacturing processes

Naturally flame-resistant

Don't see your favorite option? Add it.

One sec!