Here’s the Deal

guacamole vs ssh -X or ssh -Y

2 0

6 0

When comparing guacamole vs ssh -X or ssh -Y, the Slant community recommends ssh -X or ssh -Y for most people. In the question“What are the best Linux platforms/tools for virtualizing GUI apps and viewing them remotely?” ssh -X or ssh -Y is ranked 1st while guacamole is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose ssh -X or ssh -Y is:

In the parts of the world that are relevant to me, anyway, which is GNU/Linux and BSDs. On Windows you can use it with putty and Xming, on Mac there's also an Xserver which you can definitely use for this... Though I don't know whether these would also work for a server, but who wants non-*NIX on a server anyway.

Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking

Common Questions

What are the best Linux platforms/tools for virtualizing GUI apps and viewing them remotely?

guacamole

ssh -X or ssh -Y

Pros

Pro
Support for many clients

Using standard web application protocols supports many clients

Pro
Supports both VNC or RDP

supports multiple target desktop protocols

Pro
Pretty much everywhere available

In the parts of the world that are relevant to me, anyway, which is GNU/Linux and BSDs.
On Windows you can use it with putty and Xming, on Mac there's also an Xserver which you can definitely use for this... Though I don't know whether these would also work for a server, but who wants non-*NIX on a server anyway.

Pro
Low-level transmission of GUI I/O

Makes things run pretty smoothly in a LAN. And it's not even that bad over internet.

Pro
Combined with other tools can let you continue developing from anywhere right where you left off

SSH by itself allows you to run commands on another machine. Together with Vim (or a good console text editor) and Tmux (for window management), you can just connect to your development machine, code and test. This allows to continue where you left off and instantly work.

Pro
Supports side-channel tunneling of other services

SSH has the ability to create forwarded port mappings, SOCKS5-compatible proxies and perform file transfers, without the need for additional tools or permissions.