When comparing Halo: The Master Chief Collection vs Borderlands: The Handsome Collection, the Slant community recommends Borderlands: The Handsome Collection for most people. In the question“What are the best FPS (first person shooter) games on Xbox One?” Borderlands: The Handsome Collection is ranked 3rd while Halo: The Master Chief Collection is ranked 28th. The most important reason people chose Borderlands: The Handsome Collection is:
Borderlands is a lot more fun when you play it together with your friends. It's not just due to the excitement of going on an adventure together, it's also because the teamwork feels rewarding and meaningful. The various characters and guns have their strengths and weaknesses, so you can cover for each others weaknesses. It creates an experience where you learn to rely on each other and forge a stronger bond as a result.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Every game other than Halo 2 runs at 1080p and 60fps
Three of the four games have 1080p upgrades to them, which is great for those that want to revisit the franchise or who are new to it, to be able to have better clarity and visuals.
Pro Local split screen on all 4 titles
The whole game allows for local split screen multiplayer, something that is a bit of a lost feature nowadays with online play. This makes for a great party game as many users can trade off on controllers per match on one TV.
Pro Awesome co-op experience
Borderlands is a lot more fun when you play it together with your friends. It's not just due to the excitement of going on an adventure together, it's also because the teamwork feels rewarding and meaningful.
The various characters and guns have their strengths and weaknesses, so you can cover for each others weaknesses. It creates an experience where you learn to rely on each other and forge a stronger bond as a result.
Pro Exciting loot collection
Every time you kill an enemy or open a chest an item can drop. There are millions of possible combinations, each with their unique appearances and stats, so you never know what you'll get. It can be a really weak but rainbow-colored rifle, or an exceptionally powerful golden shotgun. The potential to find the best loot in the most humble locations makes killing enemies and finding chests incredibly exciting and satisfying.
Pro Great variety of character classes
Both games in the collection have 6 character classes (12 total). Each one has unique abilities that are affected by the skill trees, allowing you to further specialize your character to suit your playstyle. You can choose the support skills to help your teammates, defensive skills if you like being in the middle of the action, or offensive skills to quickly destroy enemies at the cost of increased risk. There's enough variety to keep it fresh across multiple playthroughs of two very similar games.
Pro Really good value for its price
The Handsome Collection contains Borderlands 2 and Borderlands: TPS with all of their DLC included, which gives you more than 100 hours of exciting content. Before this collection was released you'd have to spend more than $100 to get all the DLC for these 2 games.
Cons
Con Halo 2 does not run at 1080p
While the rest of the games in the collection run in 1080p, Halo 2 does not as it runs at 1328 by 1080.
Con You can't change splitscreen settings in Borderlands: TPS
The screen is split vertically when you play 2 player coop, creating massive blindspots on the sides. This is really inconvenient when playing FPS games since you won't see enemies trying to flank you.
Con Can get repetitive over long play sessions
The gameplay is very simple at its core - you get a new mission, shoot/beat up everyone, loot items, rinse, and repeat. After doing this multiple times it can start feeling a bit dull, especially at the lower levels when your character doesn't have many abilities unlocked to keep it interesting. It might be better to stick to short play sessions, which could prevent you from burning out.