When comparing Murdered: Soul Suspect vs Detective Grimoire, the Slant community recommends Detective Grimoire for most people. In the question“What are the best murder mystery video games?” Detective Grimoire is ranked 7th while Murdered: Soul Suspect is ranked 10th. The most important reason people chose Detective Grimoire is:
The whole game is laid out in an intuitive manner, from the menus to traversing each level. What's more the player is able to easily see where they need to go through highlighted objects on the map as well as receive hints when stuck.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Twist to the normal detective story
The base of the game is that the player must solve their own murder, making for something a bit different from the normal fair of a detective game.
Pro Easily played on most platforms
Available on the PC, PlayStation 3, PlayStation 4, Xbox 360 and Xbox One allows one to choose their favorite platform to play on.
Pro Easy to navigate
The whole game is laid out in an intuitive manner, from the menus to traversing each level. What's more the player is able to easily see where they need to go through highlighted objects on the map as well as receive hints when stuck.
Pro Well written and acted
The characters are fleshed out well through good writing and great voice acting, which makes for an immersive experience that feels believable even though the games story is a bit outlandish.
Cons
Con Environments are very confined
The environments in game only differ sightly and are pretty limited in the scope that they can be explored. For a "sandbox" game the sandbox is pretty small.
Con Could be more challenging
Traditionally point and click adventure games have a difficult edge to their puzzles but sadly Detective Grimoire contains puzzles that are often easy, making for not much of a challenge for those that are fans of the genre.
Con Poor mix of easy children aimed content and an adult theme of murder
The games looks may appeal to children but sadly the content contained withing revolves around murder, which is not much of a kid friendly topic.