When comparing Knock-knock vs Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition, the Slant community recommends Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition for most people. In the question“What are the best scary games for OSX?” Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition is ranked 2nd while Knock-knock is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition is:
Throughout the game the player is tasked with opening doors, rolling barrels, or pulling open drawers, this is done by using certain mouse motions to complete, so say for instance if one wants to open a drawer they need to not only click on it but hold the click while making a pulling motion with the mouse. It is through this realistic portrayal of interaction that allows one to feel immersed in the game environment.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Playing gives a feeling of an "experience"
As the game progresses the player ascends deeper and deeper into the characters madness that more and more is the users fault, or so the game makes one feel that way. There is a sense of dread as one explores as well and when combining these feelings one can't help but feel not only responsible for what is happening but also be frightened of it.
Pro Fresh experience every time played
Each level is randomly generated, so each play session is fresh to the player making for a new experience each time played as to not become repetitive.
Pro In game physics provide a sense of immersion
Throughout the game the player is tasked with opening doors, rolling barrels, or pulling open drawers, this is done by using certain mouse motions to complete, so say for instance if one wants to open a drawer they need to not only click on it but hold the click while making a pulling motion with the mouse. It is through this realistic portrayal of interaction that allows one to feel immersed in the game environment.
Pro Intuitive puzzles that can be solved realistically
Penumbra offers puzzles in a realistic setting where if one wants to get pas say some oil barrels, the obvious solution is that you can burn them. It is through using puzzles that ask for logical solutions that the game sets itself apart from many puzzle games where solving is not quite so logical.
Cons
Con No guidelines or help
While it is by design there is no real purpose outlined in the game nor is there any tutorial that explains anything, it is up to the player to figure out how the game works. This can be frustrating for some players.
Con Sub-par graphics
While the gameplay itself is pretty good the graphics hold the game back as they look pretty poor.