When comparing Avant Window Navigator vs Lighthouse, the Slant community recommends Lighthouse for most people. In the question“What are the best app launchers for UNIX-like systems?” Lighthouse is ranked 26th while Avant Window Navigator is ranked 27th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Tons of plugins
AWN comes with a big selections of applets such as a CPU monitor or clock or trash bin. This means one can easily turn the docks functionality into that of a taskbar. There is even an app launcher applet that will group all of ones apps in one place just like a start menu.
Pro Easily customized
There is a wide array of setting available to theming and customizing the dock.
Cons
Con Project is dead
Has not been update since 2013 and has been already pulled from many repos. While it still can be installed and works as it did in 2013, no more fixes or features are expected.
Con Dead project
Last commit (e32ff2e), was on Nov 22, 2016.
The AUR package was disowned by jade1 as "it was segfaulting and I can't be bothered to debug it"