When comparing Naturalizer Michelle vs Cole Haan Fair Haven Pump (85mm) , the Slant community recommends Cole Haan Fair Haven Pump (85mm) for most people. In the question“What are the best work appropriate nude pumps (for a light skin tone) for under $300?” Cole Haan Fair Haven Pump (85mm) is ranked 1st while Naturalizer Michelle is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Cole Haan Fair Haven Pump (85mm) is:
The matte leather makes the shoe disappear when matched correctly to skin tone.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Extra cushioning
Naturalizer uses the N5 Comfort system footbed to really up the arch support and padding on the shoes
Pro Extended sizes available
Not only are there 4 widths, but also the shoes go up to size 12
Pro Beautiful Matte leather
The matte leather makes the shoe disappear when matched correctly to skin tone.
Cons
Con Runs narrow
Women with bunions or slightly wider or average width feet may need to size up to wide or extra wide
Con Very high heel
Very high and thin heel can make it harder to last all day walking in these pumps