When comparing Meliora Testlab vs XQual XStudio, the Slant community recommends Meliora Testlab for most people. In the question“What are the best software tools for test management?” Meliora Testlab is ranked 3rd while XQual XStudio is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Meliora Testlab is:
If a project needs to get started with testing ASAP, Meliora Testlab allows users to get to that stage using a "simple workflow" which means that the project and the test cases don't need to be reviewed, simply add test cases and start testing.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Supports a simple workflow to quickly start testing
If a project needs to get started with testing ASAP, Meliora Testlab allows users to get to that stage using a "simple workflow" which means that the project and the test cases don't need to be reviewed, simply add test cases and start testing.
Pro Jenkins integration
Meliora Testlab can run automated testing through Jenkins CI.
Pro Powerful team collaboration features
Meliora Test Lab has some powerful features which make team collaboration easy and painless. Things like assignments and real-time notifications help a lot when working with teams.
Pro Free community edition available
XStudio has a free comunity edition available for up to 4 users and 200 tests.
Pro Can interface with any automation framework, even proprietary
XQual provides more than 50 drivers to interface with all the automation tools in the market but also an SDK that gives the ability to develop ones own if they have a proprietary framework for instance.
Pro Nice design
The GUI is really nice and easy to use for a such complete product. Usually, when you have all those features (ability to drive automated tests, parametrization etc.) this becomes quickly messy. No problem here... it's very clean and nicely designed.
Cons
Con Dashboard configuration is not based on roles
Some configurations, including dashboard configuration are not based on roles, which means that each team member needs to setup the dashboard themselves.
Con Supports only one way integrations
Integrations with external systems (for example Jira) are only one-way. This means that while you can submit bugs which will be tracked by Jira, changes in Jira itself are not fed back to XStudio.