Here’s the Deal

Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt vs J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt

1 0

2 0

When comparing Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt vs J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt, the Slant community recommends J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt for most people. In the question“What are the best pencil skirts for winter weather? ” J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt is ranked 1st while Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt is:

This is J. Crew's permanent collection line, meaning that while the classic colors (black, navy) are available all the time, every year there are new colors released in trendy colors.

Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking

Common Questions

What are the best pencil skirts for winter weather?

Ann Taylor Boiled Wool Skirt

J Crew No 2 Pencil Skirt

Pros

Pro
Often discounted

Ann Taylor often holds 40% off sales so this skirt can be bought at a good discount

Pro
Flared silhouette

Allows you to wear tights underneath the skirt for additional warmth and won't look lumpy because the skirt is flared

Pro
Classical and seasonal color options

This is J. Crew's permanent collection line, meaning that while the classic colors (black, navy) are available all the time, every year there are new colors released in trendy colors.

Pro
Wool

Wool will keep you warm in winter and in colder climates. The wool is thick and has a substantial weight. Can wear fleece lined tights underneath for additional warmth!

Cons

Con
Not a true pencil skirt

More of an a-line or flared silhouette

Con
Waist is large

The waist tends to run large, especially for women with curvier hips, and may require tailoring. Buy the size that fits your largest measurement (hips or waist) and tailor down to fit perfectly.