When comparing Test Collab vs Meliora Testlab, the Slant community recommends Meliora Testlab for most people. In the question“What are the best software tools for test management?” Meliora Testlab is ranked 3rd while Test Collab is ranked 6th. The most important reason people chose Meliora Testlab is:
If a project needs to get started with testing ASAP, Meliora Testlab allows users to get to that stage using a "simple workflow" which means that the project and the test cases don't need to be reviewed, simply add test cases and start testing.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Free plan
Pro Bug tracker integration
TestCollab enjoys full bi-directional integration with the most popular bug trackers.
Pro Test Automation support
Pro Bi-directional integration
Pro Can either be self-hosted or hosted through a SaaS
TestCollab gives users flexibility in choosing their hosting method. They can either choose a self-hosted plan if they want to host the software on their servers or they can choose a hosted plan to host it on the cloud.
Pro Versioning and Reusability of test cases
Pro Supports agile methodologies
Pro Supports a simple workflow to quickly start testing
If a project needs to get started with testing ASAP, Meliora Testlab allows users to get to that stage using a "simple workflow" which means that the project and the test cases don't need to be reviewed, simply add test cases and start testing.
Pro Jenkins integration
Meliora Testlab can run automated testing through Jenkins CI.
Pro Powerful team collaboration features
Meliora Test Lab has some powerful features which make team collaboration easy and painless. Things like assignments and real-time notifications help a lot when working with teams.
Cons
Con No custom reports
TestCollab does not offer the option to create custom reports.
Con Dashboard configuration is not based on roles
Some configurations, including dashboard configuration are not based on roles, which means that each team member needs to setup the dashboard themselves.