When comparing Analog Reviews vs OldManMurray, the Slant community recommends OldManMurray for most people. In the question“Who are the best game critics? ” OldManMurray is ranked 10th while Analog Reviews is ranked 11th. The most important reason people chose OldManMurray is:
There are games so bad, that while playing them comes a point where the experience and the opinion on said game is unsalvageable. At that point one can, in good faith, review the game without finishing it. And then there are games that blow up monitors.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Knowledgeable about the subject
The writing of the channels shows great knowledge about the topic at hand and all opinions and critique are given with great arguments and reasoning.
Pro Aproachable Steam group
Analog Reviews provides a Steam Group to their viewers where they can play games with them as well as discuss the games on the platform where they are purchased.
Pro The originators of Wolpaw's law
There are games so bad, that while playing them comes a point where the experience and the opinion on said game is unsalvageable. At that point one can, in good faith, review the game without finishing it. And then there are games that blow up monitors.
Pro True objective reviews by the way of "Crate Review System"
Inventors of the only truly objective review system - Crate Review System. The point you encounter a Crate in the game signifies when the developers have run out of new ideas, the longer it takes to encounter a Crate the better the game (e.g. it takes longer to encounter a Crate in Blood than it takes in Half-Life, therefore Blood is the better game game).
Cons
Con Sometime slow to add new videos
While it is mostly impossible to make enough money (especially for four people) doing Youtube reviews as a full time job there can be lulls in the uploads to this channel.
Con No longer updated
Sadly the site is no longer used and is only up for archival purposes.