When comparing Analog Reviews vs Jim Sterling, the Slant community recommends Jim Sterling for most people. In the question“Who are the best game critics? ” Jim Sterling is ranked 9th while Analog Reviews is ranked 11th. The most important reason people chose Jim Sterling is:
Jim Sterling is known for stepping on toes once in a while. In 2009 he gave Assassin's Creed II a 4 our of 10 when most reviewers praised the game, he heavily criticised Peter Molyneyx, a respected industry figure, for constantly overselling and under-delivering his games and manipulating the consumers, etc.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Knowledgeable about the subject
The writing of the channels shows great knowledge about the topic at hand and all opinions and critique are given with great arguments and reasoning.
Pro Aproachable Steam group
Analog Reviews provides a Steam Group to their viewers where they can play games with them as well as discuss the games on the platform where they are purchased.
Pro Not afraid to speak his mind
Jim Sterling is known for stepping on toes once in a while. In 2009 he gave Assassin's Creed II a 4 our of 10 when most reviewers praised the game, he heavily criticised Peter Molyneyx, a respected industry figure, for constantly overselling and under-delivering his games and manipulating the consumers, etc.
Pro Pro-consumer attitude
Jim Sterling has criticised Valve's Steam Greenlight for having a lack of quality control, multiple developers of "asset flipping" (presenting ready-made game engine assets as a game), the mainstream media for portraying games as causing violence, etc.
Pro Thank God for Him
Cons
Con Sometime slow to add new videos
While it is mostly impossible to make enough money (especially for four people) doing Youtube reviews as a full time job there can be lulls in the uploads to this channel.
Con Can be seen as overly hostile
As Sterling has a tendency to cover (often touchy) topics in a somewhat inflammatory, unapologetic manner, he often gets perceived as being needlessly hostile.
Con Is little more than a populist rabble rouser
Whatever gamers are upset about this week, expect the Jimquisition to be following along promptly with a preachy, whiny summation of things everyone said already.