When comparing BP. Trolley Ankle Boot vs Rag & Bone Classic Newbury Boot, the Slant community recommends Rag & Bone Classic Newbury Boot for most people. In the question“What are the best taupe ankle boots that are comfortable enough for work? ” Rag & Bone Classic Newbury Boot is ranked 2nd while BP. Trolley Ankle Boot is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Rag & Bone Classic Newbury Boot is:
Newbury boots have been around since 2009 and have not gone out of style. This boot, in a classic, neutral color, is a "Buy it for life" shoe. With good care of the suede, using a cobbler, the shoes should last forever. They are instantly recognizable and are commonly seen in fashion magazines, on celebrities, and more.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Minimal Embellishment
One zipper on the inside to get into boot. No buckles or shiny hardware makes this boot very minimalistic and "wear anywhere"
Pro Classic investment piece
Newbury boots have been around since 2009 and have not gone out of style. This boot, in a classic, neutral color, is a "Buy it for life" shoe. With good care of the suede, using a cobbler, the shoes should last forever. They are instantly recognizable and are commonly seen in fashion magazines, on celebrities, and more.
Pro High but comfortable heel
Heel is 3.5" but feels smaller. The block heel makes it more stable and works well for commuting to work and walking throughout the office
Pro Permanent Collection
Launched in 2009, the Newbury boot is one of Rag & Bone's signature shoes and is restocked in the classic colors, as well as seasonal colors, every year. This makes it easy to get the shoe fixes and is instantly recognizable.
Cons
Con Inconsistent Sizing
Sizing is inconsistent between different leather colors and even in sizes. Some larger sizes run small, some smaller sizes run big. Ordering a few sizes is best.
Con High price point - $525
High price point - $525 without sale. Often are not included in friends/family sales on department store sites, but can be found for 25-40% off new during department store sales, or for 100-200$ used on consignment.
Con Suede
Suede can be ruined and stained easily in the rain and through dirt