When comparing BP. Trolley Ankle Boot vs Sam Edelman Petty , the Slant community recommends Sam Edelman Petty for most people. In the question“What are the best taupe ankle boots that are comfortable enough for work? ” Sam Edelman Petty is ranked 1st while BP. Trolley Ankle Boot is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Sam Edelman Petty is:
Ankle length boots can be worn with short dresses, skinny jeans, or even flare jeans, and dressed up or down with jean cut offs or work wear or even asual dreses
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Minimal Embellishment
One zipper on the inside to get into boot. No buckles or shiny hardware makes this boot very minimalistic and "wear anywhere"
Pro Ankle length
Ankle length boots can be worn with short dresses, skinny jeans, or even flare jeans, and dressed up or down with jean cut offs or work wear or even asual dreses
Pro Waterproof
Leather options (non-suede) will be waterproof in light rain
Pro Classic colors
Black or taupe will work with any outfit
Pro Small heel
Small heel makes you taller and gives you a bit of arch support, without damaging your feet
Cons
Con Inconsistent Sizing
Sizing is inconsistent between different leather colors and even in sizes. Some larger sizes run small, some smaller sizes run big. Ordering a few sizes is best.