When comparing Nine West Toastie Dark Red Leather vs Pikolinos Royal W4D-3543AA, the Slant community recommends Pikolinos Royal W4D-3543AA for most people. In the question“What are the best women's oxblood oxfords with monk straps for $150 to $400? ” Pikolinos Royal W4D-3543AA is ranked 1st while Nine West Toastie Dark Red Leather is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Pikolinos Royal W4D-3543AA is:
Buckles can be adjusted for comfort and different foot shapes
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Comfortable footbed
The footbed and insole is slightly padded, and there is space for additional insoles
Pro Simple, sleek design
The shoe's standout feature is the monk strap, so the rest of it is sleek and simple with a nice matte leather
Pro Adjustable buckles
Buckles can be adjusted for comfort and different foot shapes
Pro Subtle broguing detail
There's a bit of broguing on the toe which gives the shoe some extra details
Pro Very comfortable
The shoe is very comfortable due to removable insole
Cons
Con Leather starts out stiff
The leather is stiff for the first few wears and not very soft, but loosens up with more wears
Con Can be hard to get on
The buckles are stiff and a bit hard to get on, or need a shoe horn
Alternative Products
