When comparing Road Not Taken vs You Must Build a Boat, the Slant community recommends You Must Build a Boat for most people. In the question“What are the best puzzle roguelike games?” You Must Build a Boat is ranked 3rd while Road Not Taken is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose You Must Build a Boat is:
This allows the user to go back to levels and try to beat their time in each, which makes for good replayability.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro In game notebook keeps track of recipes even after death
Most roguelikes, that when the player dies sees that they looses everything upon death to be forced to start from scratch to play again. Road not Taken is similar but with one tweak that the game has an in game notebook that remembers the players discovered recipes, even after death. This way some info is retained after death that can help the player when they start over.
Pro Deep crafting mechanics
With over 200 items in the game that can be combined the user has plenty of options to experiment with in order to discover new recipes. These recipes allow for one to craft useful items that will help them advance in the game.
Pro Keeps track of time played
This allows the user to go back to levels and try to beat their time in each, which makes for good replayability.
Pro Smooth, polished gameplay
Eighty Eight Games took what they learned from their previous title 10000000 and refined it even further while adding new mechanics to make a smooth cycle of matching tiles and leveling up that never gets dull or grindy.
Cons
Con Little end-game satisfaction
Beating the game can feel a bit lackluster as the game does not really push the point of the story or really leave the player intrigued as to want to go back and find the other secrets in the game.
Con Simple presentation
While a current trend the simplistic graphics and music may turn some people off when looking for a current game. The gameplay itself is fantastic but the 8bit style graphics do look pretty low effort.