When comparing Calvin Klein Cocoon Coat vs Jessica Simpson Walker Coat, the Slant community recommends Jessica Simpson Walker Coat for most people. In the question“What are the best light pink wool coats for $150 or less? ” Jessica Simpson Walker Coat is ranked 1st while Calvin Klein Cocoon Coat is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Jessica Simpson Walker Coat is:
The textured weave on the coat is unique and makes the coat stand out.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Slit pockets don't disturb the line of the coat
As the slit pockets are positioned in line with the seamlines of the jacket, it preserves the clean vertical lines of the coat
Pro Cocoon style is on trend
Pro Large size range
4 - 14
Pro Unique texture
The textured weave on the coat is unique and makes the coat stand out.
Pro Zip through stand up collar keeps the wind out
The zip continues all the way to the points of the collar to allow you to zip the collar up in particularly cold or windy conditions.
Pro Double closure helps to keep warm
Instead of just buttons, this jacket has buttons and a zipper to really cut out the cold.
Cons
Con Single button closure will be quite breezy
Only having a single button closure would not be ideal for cold and windy climates as it would not be effective at keeping the wind out - more fashion than functional
Con Not a wool coat so not as warm
Polyester/rayon/spandex blend
Con Dry clean only
Con Expensive
While the sale price is closer to what this question is asking for ($159.25), the regular price is quite a bit higher ($325).
Con Not a pure wool coat so not as warm
Made of a wool blend with only 40% wool in the garment
Con Dry clean only
Con Runs small
Alternative Products
