When comparing Recoll vs Find Any File, the Slant community recommends Find Any File for most people. In the question“What are the best alternatives to Spotlight, for searching files on a Mac?” Find Any File is ranked 4th while Recoll is ranked 9th. The most important reason people chose Find Any File is:
The fatest way to find all files (including those not indexed by Spotlight) on APFS volumes, as it's the only tool to use the faster searchfs() (Catalog Search) OS function.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Finds text inside zip files
Pro Python language integration
Python extension for Python 2 and Python 3.
Pro Repositories and packaged binaries available
Can be easily installed through official repositories for popular distros, or alternatively it can also be built from source.
Pro Fastest on APFS
The fatest way to find all files (including those not indexed by Spotlight) on APFS volumes, as it's the only tool to use the faster searchfs() (Catalog Search) OS function.
Pro Can search on network file servers
For instance, Spotlight is not good at searching on NAS drives, but FAF is.
Pro Can find any file, even protected and hidden files
To find any file, even those of other users, use the "Find All" search mode, which works with "root user" permissions.
Pro Faster than EasyFind
Especially on network volume searches.
Cons
Con Flawed search
Two term search fails to find documents that contain the second term that are found by searching for the first of those terms.
Con Does not index all document types natively
Since it does not index all file types natively, it may need extensions and plugins to be able to find them.
Con Too many boxes to type into
It's a lot of clicking to create your search. It should have a way of just typing what you are looking for in one box.