When comparing Pilot Metropolitan vs Platinum Preppy, the Slant community recommends Pilot Metropolitan for most people. In the question“What are the best fountain pens for beginners under $50?” Pilot Metropolitan is ranked 2nd while Platinum Preppy is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Pilot Metropolitan is:
There are fountains pens that are much more expensive than this one that don't have nearly as nice of nibs.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Great nib
There are fountains pens that are much more expensive than this one that don't have nearly as nice of nibs.
Pro Comes in Japanese Fine
Japanese grinds are narrower than their western counterparts. A Japanese fine nib is about the same or smaller than a western fine. This can be really great fun and is fantastic for cheap paper
Pro Shape
The shape looks classic and attractive. It doesn't look like a toy. It looks like an actual writing instruments that would be used by adults.
Pro Very cheap
The fountain pen is dirt cheap.
Pro Trusted manufacturer
Platinum produces some of the highest quality fountain pen, and Preppy is their answer to people asking for a fountain pen without extra care to handle.
Cons
Con Weight
The brass body of this pen is a bit on the heavy side, but it is ultimately well balanced. Long writing sessions might wear out you out a bit, but the ergonomics shouldn't hurt your wrist or anything.
Con Nib is not the best
Especially the EF nib, not smooth on daily A4 paper.