When comparing Statamic vs Publii, the Slant community recommends Publii for most people. In the question“What are the best flat-file CMS? ” Publii is ranked 9th while Statamic is ranked 14th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pro Multi-lingual support baked into the core
No need for plugins.
Pro Great support
Since it's a premium product, you have easy access to the devs, either through their Slack channel or through email or the official forums.
Pro Developers have extra incentive to maintain it, considering it's a commercial product
So it keeps the bar high. Provides extra-incentive for the developers to fix bugs and make sure it maintains solid.
Pro Can work as a static site generator
Can be used as a flat-file CMS with the option to wire-up a database if needed.
Pro Great documentation
The documentation is extremely detailed and explains everything thoroughly.
Pro WordPress import
Pro Search engine form & SEO included
Pro Free and open source
Pro Social media friendly (generates cards)
Con Not free
Limits adoption. Might not be the best choice for small/no-budget projects.
Con Mostly blog oriented
Con Poor support community
A very poor support community, and a developer who is just way too sensitive to any feedback.
Very limited free themes, that really are quite useless. Other themes cost quite a bit of money.