When comparing Nars - Radiant Creamy Concealer vs Maybelline - Fit Me Concealer, the Slant community recommends Maybelline - Fit Me Concealer for most people. In the question“What are the best under eye concealers?” Maybelline - Fit Me Concealer is ranked 2nd while Nars - Radiant Creamy Concealer is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Maybelline - Fit Me Concealer is:
Conceals dark shadows, bags and redness moderately well - visibly reduced but not totally gone as it has a more natural finish than some other concealers
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Smooth creamy consistency
Has a nice creamy consistency with a satin finish
Pro 10 shades available
Pro Colour and coverage last well
While the product can have a tendency to migrate into fine lines, the colour and coverage last fairly well during a long day. If migration and creasing are not an issue for your skin then it will last well, if they are then this would be better used as a spot/correcting concealer and not an under-eye concealer
Pro Medium-full coverage
Provides good coverage and correction for dark shadows, bags, redness and pigmentation
Pro Light-medium coverage
Conceals dark shadows, bags and redness moderately well - visibly reduced but not totally gone as it has a more natural finish than some other concealers
Pro Good cheaper substitute for Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer
Has a very similar fomula to the Nars Radiant Creamy Concealer - slightly less coverage and not as heavy - but a good option if you're not ready to commit to the price tag of the Nars
Pro Relatively light weight
Lighter weight for a creamy concealer so it doesn't look as heavy or cakey
Pro Lower price point
Comes in nicely under $10
Pro 6 shades available
Pro Smooth creamy consistency
Has a nice creamy consistency with a satin finish
Cons
Con Can appear quite dry and cakey
This concealer doesn't melt into the skin and sit with a skin like finish - it tends to sit on top which can give a cakey look and look quite drying in the under-eye region
Con Product migrates into creases/wrinkles which can be aging
While this product is promoted as a non-creasing formula, it can indeed crease and settle into fine lines around the eye making you appear much older than you are
Con Colours can be difficult to match
All of the colours tend to lean more yellow and even the fairest shade is quite dark
Con Tends to emphasize fine lines
This concealer tends to fall into fine lines and make them more prominent rather than blurring/hiding them
