When comparing Manic Panic® - High Voltage® Classic Cream Formula Hair Color vs Arctic Fox, the Slant community recommends Arctic Fox for most people. In the question“What are the best semi-permanent hair dyes for unnatural colors?” Arctic Fox is ranked 1st while Manic Panic® - High Voltage® Classic Cream Formula Hair Color is ranked 5th. The most important reason people chose Arctic Fox is:
It's bleeding only when I wash my hair with shampoo, and stains the towel. It doesn't stain my skin or pillow right after the dyeing.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Vegan friendly & cruelty free
These products are all vegan and not tested on animals
Pro Blend well
Manic Colours blend beautifully, and allow you to create new colours by doing so. You can create a very independent look with these colours.
Pro 43 colours to choose from
There are 43 colours to choose from ranging from more subtle, darker shades like Plum Passion (dark purple) to bright, outrageous colours like Mermaid (ocean teal) and Cotton Candy Pink.... Adore has more color options with better results, true to color, and little to no bleeding while Manic Panic bleeds once it gets wet.
Pro Stays bright longer
As long as you don't get your hair wet it won't bleed, so it will last, but the second you get it wet it bleeds and fades.
Pro Doesn't damage hair
Manic Panic is gentle and does not damage the hair. It actually has restorative properties, and acts as a conditioner. You can leave it in for hours without any risk to your hair. Similar to other semi permanent hair dyes that use a conditioner base like Arctic Fox, La Riche Directions, Lime Crime, Overtone, ect BUT Manic Panic will bleed like crazy and fade fast once its wet and washed.
Pro UV Reactive options
Manic panic do a select range of neon bright, UV reactive dye. These come in pink, neon green, and neon yellow.
Pro Less bleeding
It's bleeding only when I wash my hair with shampoo, and stains the towel. It doesn't stain my skin or pillow right after the dyeing.
Pro Long lasting
In comparison with other brands with red or pastel colors, Arctic Fox's poison and periwinkle colors lasted longer.
Pro Vibrant color for months!
It literally stays for months. Yes, a conditioner mixed with dye will touch it up in the shower, but it is not needed. As long as you shampoo quickly in cold water and put in conditioner right away it will stop bleeding while you finish washing up.
Pro Colors fade nicely
While some colors fade faster than others, they all fade quite nicely and don’t leave an ugly in between colors shade. They just get lighter. It also takes a while for it to fade out completely but does eventually completely wash out (usually after about 2 1/2 months) (update by some one else) I have NEVER been able to wash it out completely. Even after trying to on purpose for a month straight so i could do another color. It just fades to a pastel and kind of stays there. This is after 6+ months.
Pro Against animal cruelty
They donate 15% of their profits to animal cruelty prevention.
Pro Vegan/cruelty free
Pro Smells amazing
All 6 different colors smell amazing with a very fruity scent. It's noticeable even without unboxing the dyes.
Pro Conditions hair while coloring
Pro Beautiful and vibrant color
For bleached hair, using the product for 45 minutes, you get a beautiful and vibrant color. It is safe to leave on as long as you like.
Pro Large bottles
It comes in 4oz and 8oz bottles do you won’t have to keep repurchasing it.
Cons
Con Some colors don't stick at all
They will wash out when you are rinsing your hair.
Con Moderately high maintenance and cost
To keep these colours looking their best, it is wise to reapply after 4-5 washes maximum. In Australia, Classic Cream is approximately $25 and Amplified is $30 (Amplified is reported to last 33% longer)
Con Staining/doesn't wash out completely
As the colour washes out, it often leaves the hair with remnants of faded colour is almost impossible to wash out completely. It is best to either cut the hair, or colour over it with a darker shade than the staining.
Con Colors are not accurate
The colors do not come out as the company claims them to be.
Con Never stops bleeding
Even if you follow the directions, and use a vinegar rinse it will constantly bleed if its even a tiny bit wet whether its from sweat, hair products, etc.
Con Turns a ugly color
Can turn orange a day later.
Con Racist.
The owner of the company has been caught on video using the n word slur
Con Color doesn't stick
You put it in, leave for 45 minutes, rinse and the color doesn't hold. So you have to apply again. This doesn't happen always though. It works better if left on for as long as possible. It will not hatm your hair to do this.
Con The bottle is opaque
The bottle is not clear so you can’t see the actually color of the dye through it... although I know it saves on shelf life.
Con It fades quickly
After two hair washes the color isn't as vibrant. It starts to fade to brownish purple, although it still looks okay. For the best results, you should reapply it after 5 washes....if you lighten your hair as reccomended it wont turn brown.
Con Diluting is hard
Con Smell is sickly sweet
The smell was horribly sickly and synthetic .... really it depends on the person.