When comparing Tripadvisor vs TripIt, the Slant community recommends TripIt for most people. In the question“What are the best trip planning apps for iOS?” TripIt is ranked 1st while Tripadvisor is ranked 2nd. The most important reason people chose TripIt is:
Once you link your e-mail to TripIt, it will automatically create your itinerary for you, instead of having to forward anything or manually enter the details.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro High quantity of reviews
Tripadvisor lists tour options for many of the available attractions. Many of the individual tours have lots of recent reviews so you can get a better idea of what the experience will be like.
Pro Good for food/restaurants
Tripadvisor will usually have the not-to-miss restaurants, even if they can end up being touristy. A good yelp equivalent in non-US countries.
Pro Automatically creates itinerary
Once you link your e-mail to TripIt, it will automatically create your itinerary for you, instead of having to forward anything or manually enter the details.
Pro Access from anywhere
TripIt is available as a web app, with mobile apps for Windows Phone, Blackberry, Android and iOS.
Pro Easy to share trip plans
You can easily share your trip plans with friends and family so they'll know where you are.
Cons
Con Not usually easy to compare
Con Reviews can be outdated
Con Lack of trust in reviews
There is a lot of incentive for companies to post fake reviews in order to increase their ranking/visibility. Tripadvisor does very little to catch the false reviews, so it's hard to know what's authentic and what isn't.
Con Lots of sponsored content
Sponsored content such as sightseeing tours and hotels can clutter up the content users are actually searching for.
Con Unreliable
App drops data, doesn't update promptly, throws all questionable emails into one "unfiled" bucket and leaves it to you to sort out.
Con Pro account is expensive
To make use of the features such as sharing itineraries, alerts and the seat tracker, you have to purchase the pro account at $49/year.