When comparing Xbox 360 Wired Controller vs Xbox One Controller, the Slant community recommends Xbox 360 Wired Controller for most people. In the question“What are the best PC gaming controllers?” Xbox 360 Wired Controller is ranked 2nd while Xbox One Controller is ranked 13th. The most important reason people chose Xbox 360 Wired Controller is:
The controller is very comfortable to hold and allows you to play for hours without tiring your hands. The controller's shape is well-designed, the buttons are well positioned and not slippery. This is one of the reasons, the Xbox 360 controller has been the first go-to for many experienced gamers. Compared to the wireless option, this controller is lighter and less bulky, since it doesn't have a battery pack at the back of the controller. On the contrary, since it's wired, it does have a limited range. This means you can not move very far from the screen.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Feels comfortable
The controller is very comfortable to hold and allows you to play for hours without tiring your hands. The controller's shape is well-designed, the buttons are well positioned and not slippery. This is one of the reasons, the Xbox 360 controller has been the first go-to for many experienced gamers.
Compared to the wireless option, this controller is lighter and less bulky, since it doesn't have a battery pack at the back of the controller. On the contrary, since it's wired, it does have a limited range. This means you can not move very far from the screen.
Pro Always available and underpriced on the second-hand market
There is a large supply of these Xbox 360 controllers on the second-hand market. This is an easy way to get them for a much lower price, especially since many people don't care about price they sell it at or just aren't aware of the value of this controller.
Pro Player number indicator
The controller has a green LED circle around the home button, which shows what number player you are from 1 to 4. This can save you from confusion while focused on gameplay.
Pro Convenient plug-and-play controller
It's a convenient plug-and-play controller. There's rarely any hassle - the controller tends to always work without problems. You never have to change batteries either, which saves you from another headache.
Pro Force feedback
The controller has a strong force feedback, which adds to the gaming experience. Since the controller is wired, the vibration is stronger than on the wireless option. In addition to Xbox, many games on PC can also make use of this feature.
Pro Almost instant response time
Since the controller is wired, it has a lower response time compared to wireless options. Though the difference is usually just a few milliseconds, then in competitive gaming every millisecond of reaction time counts.
Pro Crisp, clicky and well-positioned buttons
The buttons are overall well-positioned and you don't have to reach for any of them. Compared to the older Xbox 360 controller, the buttons are also very crisp and clicky, at the same time making less noise. None of the buttons are slippery, while some of them even have rubber padding on them.
Pro Feels solid and comfortable
The controller feels very solid in hand - it doesn't give you a feeling that it could break. The shape is comfortable for longer playing sessions, even for people with bigger hands. At the same time it's noticeably lighter than the old Xbox 360 controller.
Pro Wired and wireless options
The Xbox One controller can be used wirelessly, but it comes with a cable, which allows you to use it on Windows. For a wireless connection you need to purchase an Xbox wireless adapter for Windows.
Pro Tons of customizability
You can choose between several base designs, but you can also add skins and button covers to your Xbox One Controller.
Cons
Con A-B / X-Y buttons are swapped compared to SNES controllers
The A-B and X-Y buttons are swapped on this controller, compared to SNES controllers. Swapped controls can be confusing if you mainly play SNES(Super Nitendo Entertainment System) games.
Con Need to buy an extra USB receiver
The controller needs an extra cable to convert the old connection to USB, if you plan to use it on anything else than an Xbox. The cable costs under $20, but can be found for much less.
Con Headset input is not standard
The headset input on the controller is 2.5mm, instead of the most common 3.5mm. Your headphones probably use a 3.5mm jack and you will need an adapter to use them with this remote.
Con The shoulder-buttons are hard to click
The shoulderbuttons(L1 and R1) are a little cumbersome for many users. They also click differently on the inner and outer side of the buttons, requiring different amount of force.
Con On the expensive side
The very basic Xbox One controller costs around $50. There are various editions available that cost even more.