When comparing vimagit (via vim) vs GitEye, the Slant community recommends vimagit (via vim) for most people. In the question“What are the best Git clients for macOS?” vimagit (via vim) is ranked 19th while GitEye is ranked 21st. The most important reason people chose vimagit (via vim) is:
Inspired from emacs magit workflow, vimagit provides an efficient stage/commit workflow. In the case you have a lot of work, in multiple files, in your git repository: vimagit makes it easy to split it in multiple commits.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Efficient stage/commit workflow
Inspired from emacs magit workflow, vimagit provides an efficient stage/commit workflow. In the case you have a lot of work, in multiple files, in your git repository: vimagit makes it easy to split it in multiple commits.
Pro Stage hunks or even just parts of a hunk using a single key press
Pro Native GitHub GUI support via GitHub Eclipse plugin
GitEye can be integrated with the GitHub Eclipse plugin to have support for GitHub.
Pro Custom commands can be defined that allow launching third-party tools
If you are using a lot of third-part tools besides GitEye, you can set up shortcuts to launch them easily from inside GitEye, greatly improving your workflow.
Pro Has a graphical compare and merge tool
Pro Great for those starting out with git
Cons
Con Poor documentation
The documentation isn't very detailed and does not do a good job at explaining everything.