When comparing Where's My Water? vs Puddle+, the Slant community recommends Where's My Water? for most people. In the question“What are the best physics-based puzzle games for iOS?” Where's My Water? is ranked 3rd while Puddle+ is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Where's My Water? is:
Where's My Water offers a bunch of different levels with challenging physics-based puzzles. Thanks to a great variety in the level design and different elements that interact with the water, the game succeeds to stay fresh.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Challenging puzzles
Where's My Water offers a bunch of different levels with challenging physics-based puzzles. Thanks to a great variety in the level design and different elements that interact with the water, the game succeeds to stay fresh.
Pro Great presentation and visuals
Soundtracks often aren't the most important aspect developers pay attention to, but Where's My Water certainly is an exception. Reviewers and users praise the fun soundtrack of the game, but also the overall presentation. Narrative is well handled and graphics are crisp and enjoyable.
Pro Gameplay based on physics and chemistry
Puddle is a physics based game that also uses aspects of chemistry and physics in its gameplay. For example, you'll have to deal with factors such as temperature, gravity and friction in order to complete a puzzle.
Pro Beautiful graphics
From the different environments to all of the different liquids in the game, everything looks very striking. The +-edition can take full advantage of the powerful processing chips in newer devices, for extra visual eye-candy. The design of each environment is distinctive and beautifully rendered.
Pro Support for Apple TV
Puddle+ is also compatible with the Apple TV system and is perfectly playable on a large screen with adapted Apple TV controls.
Cons
Con Some in-app purchases
Where's My Water offers a few downloadable content packs, in the form of extra levels. These can be purchased via an in-app purchase ranging from $0.99 to $2.99. There are also microtransactions to assist unlocking levels.
Con Screen navigation isn't always perfect
Some levels are bigger than the screen on your device, which means you'll have to scroll up and down constantly in order to see what's going on in a level. A scroll-bar is positioned on the left, which seems like an odd choice for right-handed people.
Con Lack of communication in levels
Apart from quickly explaining the game's mechanics, Puddle+ doesn't warn the player adequately for incoming threats. There are a lot of spots in the different levels where you lose a significant amount of your puddle for a small communication mistake that could've been avoided.
Con HDR graphics setting buggy
The newly added HDR graphics setting is bugged in that the fluid in game does not appear when used.