When comparing Edwin Jagger DE89 vs Dorco PL-602, the Slant community recommends Edwin Jagger DE89 for most people. In the question“What is the best double-edged safety razor for beginners?” Edwin Jagger DE89 is ranked 6th while Dorco PL-602 is ranked 8th. The most important reason people chose Edwin Jagger DE89 is:
This includes the Mühle R41 open comb, known for being one of the most aggressive razor heads that exposes a lot of the blade should you want a closer shave. Also includes the equally popular Edwin Jagger DE89, another mild safety-bar/closed-comb razor head similar to the R89.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Compatible with all post-2010 Edwin Jagger and Mühle heads
This includes the Mühle R41 open comb, known for being one of the most aggressive razor heads that exposes a lot of the blade should you want a closer shave. Also includes the equally popular Edwin Jagger DE89, another mild safety-bar/closed-comb razor head similar to the R89.
Pro Cheap
Made of plastic, it can be purchased new on Ebay for under $5.
Cons
Con Smooth handle finish can cause a looser grip
May weaken grip because of a relative lack of texture on the handle apart from the vertical bumps.
Con Can break easily
The plastic screw doesn't have a strong stop, and this can break the mechanism in half while screwing it back if you are not careful.
Con Fitting new blades can be cumbersome
It has a two-piece design whereby the baseplate is permanently affixed to the handle. It has two notches to place your blade on, but the blade can easily come off as you screw the head on top. It is not uncommon for blades to fall out when switching them.
Con Lacks weight, requiring more care when shaving
New wetshavers are recommended to use the weight of the razor to cut. Unfortunately, the Dorco PL-602 has next to no weight so you will have to carefully apply a small amount of pressure.