Here’s the Deal

Honeywell RTH9580WF vs Nest Learning Thermostat

8 0

14 0

When comparing Honeywell RTH9580WF vs Nest Learning Thermostat, the Slant community recommends Nest Learning Thermostat for most people. In the question“What are the best smart thermostats?” Nest Learning Thermostat is ranked 1st while Honeywell RTH9580WF is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Nest Learning Thermostat is:

Nest begins learning as soon as you install it. In a short time, it will automatically be adjusting your temperature based on time of day, or how active the house is. For the first few weeks you may need to adjust the Nest a few degrees when required, but eventually it will learn when you adjust it and will start adjusting itself automatically based on how you manually adjusted it before.

Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking

Common Questions

What are the best smart thermostats?

Honeywell RTH9580WF

Nest Learning Thermostat

Pros

Pro
Automatically works to reduce power usage

Instead of continuously heating and cooling, this thermostat can use a fan mode instead of full cooling to help preserve power while still providing adequate comfort.

Pro
Notification support keeps you in the know

If there was an extreme temperature change, Honeywell lets you know. It can also notify you when it's time to change your air filter. Notifications like these are a nice addition, as it keeps you in the loop about what's going on with your house.

Pro
Configurable schedule to suit your needs

You can schedule the settings for every day of the week through the dashboard. You can also edit your settings at any time.

Pro
Beautiful interface

The interface is extremely attractive but also informative. It will tell you the indoor temperature and humidity as well as the outdoor temperature and humidity.

Pro
Learns your preferences and adjusts accordingly

Pro
Amazing design

The Nest thermostat looks like a piece of tech from the future. It's fully circular and certainly looks the part of a smart thermostat.

The display takes up the majority of the unit, and makes good use of its LCD display when not in use. It can display an analog or digital clock instead of the temperature if you prefer.

Pro
Complete control from app

Even if you're not home, or you're in the kitchen cooking, and need to change the temperature, you can do it all from your app.

Pro
Integrates with many other products: Nest, Alexa, and IFTTT

Nest also makes other products, such as it's Nest Cam, and smart smoke detector.

Alexa is the voice assistant in the Amazon Echo line of products, and the Nest thermostat can be fully controlled by Alexa. This is important because Alexa can control devices through 100% hands-free voice support.

IFTTT (IF This Then That) is an ecosystem to itself that allows users to create their own custom recipes based on triggers. For example, if it's expected to be humid, the Nest can automatically lower its setpoint to compensate for it. You can also configure other triggers such as location or time of day to determine when the Nest is on or off.

Pro
Motion activation available for alternative mode of controll

This version of the Nest includes motion sensors that can detect motion from across the room. Previous generations of Nest could only detect motion up to a meter away, but with this generation of Nest the utility is greatly increased.

Motion sensing is useful, because it will sense when you are at home or if you are away automatically, without needing to adjust the thermostat manually.

Pro
Easy installation

The Nest Thermostat is the easiest smart thermostat to install. It comes with the required mini screwdriver, and there's a level built-in to make sure the Nest is installed properly. The included baseplate helps cover up any imperfections left from removing your previous thermostat.

Installation is straightforward, and only takes about 10 minutes.

Pro
Shows energy savings

The Nest app will actually show you how much your smart thermostat is saving you on electricity.

Ad
Cons

Con
The user interface appears cluttered

While the UI is very functional, it appears cluttered as it tries to display a bunch of information all on the same display. On the main screen, there are 4 tabs on top, two buttons to adjust the setpoint, and it displays the current indoor temperature as well. On the left it displays current information such as date, time, weather conditions, and the status of the system.

Some will appreciate this layout for its functionality, but others will find it cluttered and not appealing.

Con
Installation can be difficult

The tools you require aren't included, and depending on your HVAC system the installation can be tricky if you try to do it yourself.

Con
Doesn't learn as much

While this smart temperature can learn, it doesn't learn as much as other smart thermostats. It relies more on programming.

Con
Sensors scheduling is not smart enough

The Nest has a sensor that can be placed in other parts of the house to control the temperature but the only scheduling it offers for it is by pre-selected blocks of time (morning, evening, etc). If you need the thermostat to use the sensor at night until a specific time in the morning and then use the main thermostat you may not be able to if the time blocks don't fit your personal schedule. Seems like something that can be easily fixed through an app update though.

Con
Scheduling UI in app is terrible

The Nest has a way to set a schedule by day/time through the app but it's really hard to understand how to navigate the scheduling feature and set the schedule properly.

Con
Hardware control is through a rotating ring

On the Nest itself, the homeowner rotates the ring on the edge of the Nest as the primary way to interact with it. Most controls will need to be done through the app.