When comparing Homeworld Remastered Collection vs Spintires, the Slant community recommends Spintires for most people. In the question“What are the best PC simulation games?” Spintires is ranked 8th while Homeworld Remastered Collection is ranked 21st. The most important reason people chose Spintires is:
You do not see games like this much, it is kind of niche product. As going trough rugged terrain with hulking Soviet machines tends to be a pretty niche genre/style of game.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Unique title
You do not see games like this much, it is kind of niche product. As going trough rugged terrain with hulking Soviet machines tends to be a pretty niche genre/style of game.
Pro Has Steam Workshop support
You can get all the mod's etc through Steam Workshop, which creates a community where one can enjoy the added elements brought forth by the available mods.
Cons
Con Abysmal Homeworld 1 Remaster
Homeworld 1's engine was not updated, instead the assets were ported into the Homeworld 2 remastered engine. This introduced a lot of bugs in singleplayer and destroyed Homeworld 1's critical gameplay elements (e.g. physics simulation and formations). The original voice actors were rehired to redo their lines 17 years later and they now sound worse than the first time.
If you want to play Homeworld 1, you are better off avoiding this remaster - it is not the same game at all.
Con Camera can be unweildy
There is no cockpit camera view in the game, the only camera view is this odd over the shoulder camera that can make it tough to see what one is doing while driving. It does help when trying to hook up to and pull another truck out of the mud, but an additional camera view would be helpful for driving in particular.