When comparing Alan Wake vs The Evil Within, the Slant community recommends Alan Wake for most people. In the question“What are the best horror games for PC?” Alan Wake is ranked 9th while The Evil Within is ranked 14th. The most important reason people chose Alan Wake is:
The story of an author trying to break out of a writers block slump, who is trying to meet a deadline, decides to travel to the countryside with his wife in order to relax. Of course the wife is kidnapped as weird events start following the protagonist around. This is just the outline, but it is very fleshed out through great voice acting as well as interesting TV like scripted segments that break up the gameplay. Overall it shows a lot of polish and makes for a story that is intriguing, that player wants to stick around to resolve.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Immersive story
The story of an author trying to break out of a writers block slump, who is trying to meet a deadline, decides to travel to the countryside with his wife in order to relax. Of course the wife is kidnapped as weird events start following the protagonist around. This is just the outline, but it is very fleshed out through great voice acting as well as interesting TV like scripted segments that break up the gameplay. Overall it shows a lot of polish and makes for a story that is intriguing, that player wants to stick around to resolve.
Pro Great immersion
many parts of the game are pretty scary and creepy, making for an atmosphere that is truly fitting of a survival horror. there will be jump scares are gross out horror, which all adds up to a game that is very polished.
Cons
Con Late game drags
Sadly the late game story and gameplay drags a bit, making for a title that is stretched just a bit to long as the written and played scenarios get more and more outrageous.
Con Non cohesive levels
There are certain sections of the game that sees the player sneaking around, which really limits exploration in the game. While many parts of the game are very fitting for a survival horror title, some sections leave the player wanting.