When comparing Advanced Renamer vs Rename-It!, the Slant community recommends Advanced Renamer for most people. In the question“What are the best bulk rename tools for Windows?” Advanced Renamer is ranked 4th while Rename-It! is ranked 7th.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Easily composable rules and priority ordering
Pro It does almost everything and it uses regular expressions and wildcards
Pro Portable version available
Pro Very user friendly
Pro Very user friendly
Pro Never encountered anything the program doesn't do.
Pro Regular updates and forum support
Pro Really fast and safe renaming
It can rename thousands of files in seconds and does it in a single transaction so that if anything fails it renames nothing at all.
Pro Can rename the full path
You can change file's directory or rename the full path to the file.
Pro Open source
Pro Can create numbered series
You can ask it to rename so it's Image001, Image002, etc.
Pro Supports regular expressions
Additional to wildcards, and string replacements, it can use RegExp.
Pro Incorporates in the Explorer context menu
Pro Detects cycles and handles them
If you rename A -> B and B -> A (or any cycle), it'll automatically do A -> T, B -> A, T->A.
Pro Command-line arguments
You can create a script invoking Rename-It! from the CLI with some arguments so it performs the renaming and returns the correct exit code.
Pro Can use audio file ID3 tag info
Cons
Con No great support
You may not receive any answer to your emails.
Con More advanced renames (such as presets and scripts) require some learning
And research to do the learning in the first place. It's not in-app.
Con Dated
Quite dated - last release or code update at least two years old.