When comparing Eclipse Phase vs Archipelago, the Slant community recommends Eclipse Phase for most people. In the question“What is the best free tabletop RPG?” Eclipse Phase is ranked 10th while Archipelago is ranked 23rd. The most important reason people chose Eclipse Phase is:
The setting, like everything about Eclipse Phase, is great. It has depth and scope, offering a huge array of themes and prospects for adventure, though underlying it all is a noir, tragic feeling, both refined and raw. There´s no subterfuge or apologies. The world is violent, it´s deadly, it´s a tragic affair but one the beckons living. There´s a universe out there to discover but you have to look no further than your own habitat to find both light and darkness, and most of all shadow.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Great setting
The setting, like everything about Eclipse Phase, is great.
It has depth and scope, offering a huge array of themes and prospects for adventure, though underlying it all is a noir, tragic feeling, both refined and raw. There´s no subterfuge or apologies. The world is violent, it´s deadly, it´s a tragic affair but one the beckons living. There´s a universe out there to discover but you have to look no further than your own habitat to find both light and darkness, and most of all shadow.
Pro High standard of quality
Production value and quality of each and every product is on par with the best, and far, far above your average RPG, even your classic "best sellers".
Pro Comprehensive and intuitive D100 system
The basic mechanics are easy and familiar but it offers a robust system that can deal with pretty much anything you can thrown at it.
Pro Considered one of the best story games
It's a very story-focused game and it's considered one of the best story games available.
Cons
Con If you don't like Story Games this is not for you
.