When comparing APC P11VT3 vs Belkin BP112230-08, the Slant community recommends Belkin BP112230-08 for most people. In the question“What are the best surge protectors?” Belkin BP112230-08 is ranked 1st while APC P11VT3 is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Belkin BP112230-08 is:
It has a clamping threshold of 330V which is about as low as it can get. The clamping voltage indicates when the device will start to redirect the excess electricity away from the plugged-in devices. The lower the better.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro When it dies, some outlets keep providing power while others don't
Some outlets will completely cut off their power once the surge protection ends while others will keep running. This is the best of both worlds as you can choose to use the outlets which continue running specifically for electronics which shouldn’t be unexpectedly turned off, like computers. And use the rest of the outlets for electronics that won’t be impacted by a sudden power outage, like a radio.
Pro Another protection against an overload
It has its own circuit breaker. If a component fails inside the surge protector, then only the protector’s circuit breaker will switch off. This way the failed component won’t shut off power for the whole house.
Pro High joule rating
It has a high joule rating of 3020. This generally indicates how much electricity it can divert before it stops functioning. The length of the time is also largely dependent on weather and other connected electronics.
Pro Ensures very basic outlet protection
All of the power sockets have safety covers to protect the outlets from random particles or to protect children from potential danger.
Pro Lifetime warranty
The manufacturer offers lifetime warranty and promises to reimburse up to $100,000 worth of equipment if it is damaged by a power surge while their surge protector is active.
Pro Can be placed in various spots
It can be mounted on a wall and the outgoing cable can be rotated by 180 degrees to prevent it from being damaged when situated in tight spaces. In addition, it comes with a cable management strap to neatly organize all the cables.
Pro Panel has space for big power plugs
The six outer outlets are spread out to allow for big power plugs to be plugged in without covering other sockets.
Pro Low clamping voltage
It has a clamping threshold of 330V which is about as low as it can get. The clamping voltage indicates when the device will start to redirect the excess electricity away from the plugged-in devices. The lower the better.
Pro High surge suppression rating
It has an impressive suppression rating of 4320 joules. This rating generally indicates how much energy it can absorb across its lifespan.
Pro Creative outlet design
Eight out of twelve available outlets can be rotated up to 90 degrees to create space for big power plugs. This is a creative design that allows the panel to be relatively compact while still being able to power many sockets.
Pro Additional conveniences
It can be wall mounted for more placement options, and also has a cable management clip to help organize the connected wires more efficiently.
Cons
Con Higher chance of damaging the plugged-in devices compared to others
It has a high clamping voltage of 500V that is tied with the outlets which keep working when the protection ends. On the other hand, it has a reasonable clamping voltage of 400V on the lines that cut off power immediately. Clamping voltage is the threshold when the surge protector starts redirecting excess energy away from the plugged-in devices. Generally, a lower voltage is better.
Con Unreliably tells you when it stops protecting your devices
This surge protector will still provide power to all your connected devices even after it has stopped protecting them. To know whether it still functions, you need to check the LED’s. It isn’t as convenient as it sounds since such devices tend to be put in places out of sight. It is also possible to simply forget about its existence after multiple years of use.
Con Manufacturer doesn’t honor the warranty claim
The manufacturer has a reputation of not upholding their warranty claims. They claim to compensate for any equipment that has been damaged by power surges while connected to their surge protector. Many have reported not receiving their owed money.
Con On/off button tends to break
The on/off button has a tendency to break, but luckily, pulling out the main cable out of the wall socket can be a good work-around.