When comparing Wilkinson Classic vs Edwin Jagger DE89, the Slant community recommends Wilkinson Classic for most people. In the question“What is the best double-edged safety razor for beginners?” Wilkinson Classic is ranked 2nd while Edwin Jagger DE89 is ranked 6th. The most important reason people chose Wilkinson Classic is:
This razor isn't very scary. You can confidently use it without fear of slashing yourself.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Not very aggressive
This razor isn't very scary. You can confidently use it without fear of slashing yourself.
Pro Durable delrin body
This is a big deal for people who are very allergic to nickle. This razor doesn't have exposed nickle because it has a delrin body. There's still a nice weighted internal rod so that you can draw the razor across your skin without pulling.
Pro Compatible with all post-2010 Edwin Jagger and Mühle heads
This includes the Mühle R41 open comb, known for being one of the most aggressive razor heads that exposes a lot of the blade should you want a closer shave. Also includes the equally popular Edwin Jagger DE89, another mild safety-bar/closed-comb razor head similar to the R89.
Cons
Con Not very aggressive
You won't get a terribly close shave with this. Some people believe this teaches bad habits.
Con Cheap plastic body
You're not going to post any pictures of this online for cheap internet points because it's so pretty.
Con Smooth handle finish can cause a looser grip
May weaken grip because of a relative lack of texture on the handle apart from the vertical bumps.