When comparing BodyPaint 3D vs Substance Designer, the Slant community recommends BodyPaint 3D for most people. In the question“What are the best 3D texture painting softwares?” BodyPaint 3D is ranked 6th while Substance Designer is ranked 14th.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Very easy to learn
Pro Native integration with many game engines
It has the ability to export sbsar files, these can be put into most game engines allowing in engine tweaking of procedural content.
Pro Ability to create custom substance files
Substance designer allows users to create custom substance files, it offers a lot of power with a mix of workflow of working with procedural textures and bitmaps.
Cons
Con Bugs galore
There are programs that provide much more for much less. Specifically, it is very bug laden for such an expensive software.
Con Awful everything
Lighting changes when you turn the model. Awful interface. Very few tools.
Con Expensive
The pricing starts at $20 for the indie license and $100 for the pro license.
Con Not good for painting textures
Substance designer is not very powerful when it comes to painting textures, while there are 2D painting tools, they are not very good.