When comparing Maximiza Pull Up Bar vs Gold's Gym 5-In-1 Door Gym Trainer, the Slant community recommends Maximiza Pull Up Bar for most people. In the question“What are the best pull up bars?” Maximiza Pull Up Bar is ranked 3rd while Gold's Gym 5-In-1 Door Gym Trainer is ranked 4th. The most important reason people chose Maximiza Pull Up Bar is:
You can quickly re-attach the handle lower in the doorway and use it for push-ups with an angle and many other excercises.
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Can be used for different excercises
You can quickly re-attach the handle lower in the doorway and use it for push-ups with an angle and many other excercises.
Pro Easy to attach
You can just place it in the doorway, or attach it with screws for extra weight capacity.
Pro Comfortable handle
The bar has a soft handle to avoid damaging the skin on your palms and fingers.
Pro Perpendicular grips
Allows for a range of pull up techniques to target different muscles.
Pro Good foam padding
Pro Very affordable
Great deal if it fits your needs.
Pro Multiple uses
Can be used in several different ways (not just as a pull-up bar).
Pro Non-invasive
No screws in your door casing, or wall.
Cons
Con Unstable
Compared to wall-mount and free standing pull-up bars, this one feels very unstable and can slip off the door when excercising. Twisting the bar while doing pull-ups can unscrew and unmount the bar.
Con Weakest at the mid bar connection
This pull up bar can snap in the middle while you're in the air doing your workout, which can lead to injury.
Con Top plastic support is cheap plastic.
It can hold a decent weight, but it doesn't provide a sense of security while doing so.
Con Company has some bad reputation
There are complaints of bad customer service both about this product (their unwillingness to exchange flawed or broken items) and the gyms and their billing practices as well.
Con Not as secure as a mounted solution
The plastic support that hooks over the top of your door frame is made from cheap plastic, and has been known to snap or arrive already broken. There is also some risk with pull up bars that don't require screws and mounts to keep them in place- if the bar is not tightly assembled at all times, or by regular every day use, it can unhook itself from the door frame, leading to a fall.