When comparing Moonlight Slumber Starlight Simplicity vs Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic, the Slant community recommends Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic for most people. In the question“What are the best high-end mattresses for babies?” Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic is ranked 2nd while Moonlight Slumber Starlight Simplicity is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Naturepedic Organic Cotton Classic is:
Your baby is safer because he will be sleeping on a firm and flat surface since this mattress has 252 heavy-duty innerspring coils, plus border rods that adds support along the sides and edges of the mattress. This ensures that the mattress will not sag under the weight of the baby. Any sagging on a mattress can be a Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) risk. The U.S. [Consumer Product Safety Commission](https://www.cpsc.gov/) or CPSC [recommends that babies should sleep on their backs on top of a firm, tight-fitting mattress](https://www.cpsc.gov/content/recommendations-revised-to-prevent-infant-deaths-from-soft-bedding). If a mattress is soft and the baby rolls over, he can get molded into it and suffocate.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Resilient and durable
This mattress can be used by your baby for years to come, which is why it has an extra firm infant side and a toddler side. It will save you money since natural latex lasts longer than other conventional mattress materials while maintaining their original recoil and resilience.
Pro Made of natural materials
This mattress is made of natural latex, has a natural fabric fire barrier, a cover made of 30% organic cotton, an organic ribbon, and no spray-on flame retardants known as PBDE (polybrominated diphenyl ethers). Natural latex is resistant to dust mites and has antimicrobial and antifungal properties.
Pro Gives your baby good body support
Your baby’s weight is fully supported and the mattress is less likely to conform to your baby’s shape and create any possibility of suffocation, due to the extra firm natural latex infant side.
Pro Gives your baby good body support
Your baby is safer because he will be sleeping on a firm and flat surface since this mattress has 252 heavy-duty innerspring coils, plus border rods that adds support along the sides and edges of the mattress. This ensures that the mattress will not sag under the weight of the baby. Any sagging on a mattress can be a Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS) risk. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission or CPSC recommends that babies should sleep on their backs on top of a firm, tight-fitting mattress. If a mattress is soft and the baby rolls over, he can get molded into it and suffocate.
Pro Suitable for those prone to allergies
This Naturepedic mattress is hypoallergenic since it doesn't have any wool or latex. It's also covered with an organic cotton waterproof fabric that acts as a dustmite or bed bug barrier.
Pro Easy to clean and keep clean due to its waterproof and stain-resistant surface
Parents will be able to save a lot of time and effort because cleaning this mattress will be as simple as wiping off any spills with a damp cloth.
Cons
Con Not water resistant
The mattress cover is made of organic cotton and is not waterproof or even water resistant, so a separate pad or cover may be needed.
Con More expensive than most baby mattresses
The price of this mattress is higher than most since it uses organic and all-natural materials.