When comparing Staub Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet vs Paderno World Cuisine Grand Gourmet Stainless Steel, the Slant community recommends Paderno World Cuisine Grand Gourmet Stainless Steel for most people. In the question“What are the best skillets around or under $100?” Paderno World Cuisine Grand Gourmet Stainless Steel is ranked 1st while Staub Enameled Cast-Iron Skillet is ranked 3rd. The most important reason people chose Paderno World Cuisine Grand Gourmet Stainless Steel is:
This frying pan's stainless steel sidewalls are 1.2 mm thick (in comparison to the usual 0.8-1 mm in cheaper brands), so it is not easily dented. The surface is resistant to corrosion and rust while metal utensils can be used without issue.
Specs
Ranked in these QuestionsQuestion Ranking
Pros
Pro Can be used to cook acidic foods
Since this skillet's enamel is non-reactive, nothing from the cooking surface leaches into food, even when exposed to highly acidic foodstuffs. As a result, pasta sauce, chili or anything else can simmer for a long time or even be stored in the pan.
Pro Suitable for various cooking mediums
The enameled Staub skillet can be used with these heat sources: gas/electric/induction stove-tops, oven, broiler, and grill, although using a grill risks damaging the pan's outer glossy enamel layer.
Pro Dishwasher safe
This skillet can be washed or soaked in water without rusting. However, with frequent dishwasher cycles it will need reseasoning and the enamel may wear out.
Pro Very versatile use
This skillet is suitable for a wide variety of uses, for example, searing, roasting, frying, baking, and simmering.
Pro Spouts for easier pouring
This frying pan has spouts on two sides, so it is easy to pour out grease or gravy.
Pro An extra handle for easier handling
Since the skillet is heavy, it has an extra handle for added balance when moving the pan.
Pro Wide range of colors
The skillet comes in 8 colors: matte black, white, sapphire blue, grenadine red, graphite grey, basil green, burnt orange and cherry red. The glossy outside enamel looks appealing and decorative.
Pro Can handle high heat
This Staub skillet can be used in temperatures of up to 500 ºF. However, the manufacturer advises users to use mostly low to medium heat. If high temperatures are needed, it should be heated up slowly.
Pro Comes preseasoned for immediate use
This skillet comes with a first layer of seasoning and can be used right away. The cooking surface of Staub's enamel is a little rough, so it allows for some more seasoning. This can be done by cooking greasy foods for the first few times.
Pro Durable and less prone to dents
This frying pan's stainless steel sidewalls are 1.2 mm thick (in comparison to the usual 0.8-1 mm in cheaper brands), so it is not easily dented. The surface is resistant to corrosion and rust while metal utensils can be used without issue.
Pro Heats very evenly and is excellent at retaining heat
This skillet has a very thick 7 mm aluminum disc base clad with steel. As a result, the heat distributes evenly, there are no hot spots, and the ability to retain heat is very high.
Pro Less likely to warp
When cold, this skillet has a concave bottom, which goes flat when expanding with heat. That way it avoids warping, which is quite frequent to stainless steel skillets used on a ceramic glass electric stovetop.
Pro Suitable for various cooking mediums
The Grand Paderno can be used with these heat sources: gas/electric/induction stove-tops, oven, and broiler.
Pro Versatile use
This frying pan is suitable for a variety of uses like searing, sautéing, flambéing, braising, and making sauces.
Pro Handle stays cool
The stainless steel handle of this skillet is hollow, engineered to stay cool even when the skillet itself gets very hot.
Pro No rivets to collect grime
This skillet's handle is welded on, so the inside surface is even and undisrupted by rivet heads. Food residue, grime, and bacteria get in the cracks between the rivet heads and the pan's surface; it can take a lot of work with a fine brush to clean the rivets effectively.
Pro Can handle acidic or alkaline foodstuffs
Because of its non-reactive cooking surface, stainless steel can handle any acidic or alkaline food like tomatoes, citrus, wine or pineapple without the metals corroding or leaching.
Pro Dishwasher safe
This skillet can be put in the dishwasher without any concern. If some food is firmly stuck, it can be removed by boiling a little water in the pan.
Cons
Con Enamel is not resistant to scratches
Only wooden, nylon or plastic utensils should be used in this skillet, otherwise the enamel might chip. Enamel also may crack if the skillet gets banged against a hard surface.
Con Does not heat up very evenly
The enameled frying pan distributes heat more evenly in comparison to bare-cast iron pans, but preheating is still needed to eliminate hot spots.
Con Very heavy
Weighing 6.6 lbs, this skillet may not be suitable for cooks with weaker wrists.
Con The handle gets very hot
The skillet should not be handled without gloves or potholders, because the handle gets very hot when cooking.
Con Sensitive to sudden changes in temperature
To use with high heat, this skillet should be heated up slowly for 10 minutes. When heated up, it should never be cooled suddenly (such as plunged in cold water), as the enamel coating may crack and come off entirely.
Con Not suitable for using on a campfire
Unlike the bare-cast iron skillets, this enameled skillet should not be put straight into campfires. The temperatures of open flames are hard to control, and if the skillet gets too hot, the enamel can soften enough to get damaged.
Con Expensive brand
The 10'' skillet version is the cheapest, costing $99.95. The next in size 12'' skillet costs double that - $199.95.
Con The outer edges of the cooking surface do not heat up well
The disc base doesn't cover the whole bottom of this skillet. As a result, there is a 0.5'' ring around the bottom of the pan which does not heat as evenly as the rest of the cooking surface.
Con Needs oil when cooking
This skillet does not have a non-stick coating. It needs to be heated up, then coated with oil or some other fat, otherwise the food will get burned and stuck to the pan.
Con Has no complementing glass lid
Paderno does not make glass lids for the skillets, only stainless steel (available for purchase separately), so a third party lid might be needed. Stainless steel lids can go in the oven and can handle high heat; however, a see-through glass lid makes it a lot easier to check on food without losing the steam or the heat.